Ask Q (5/4/13)

[Master Q]

Time to start up my weekly Friday afternoon thread  :)

Ask me your questions and I'll give you my honest opinion  ;)

Oh, and a small plug. Vote for me in the POTY  :P

[hally25547]

Hey mate,

Who should I start out of Macaffer, Neade and Rowe?

Cheers

[Master Q]

Hey mate,

Who should I start out of Macaffer, Neade and Rowe?

Cheers

Macaffer for security. Neade has good JS but not much of a scorer, not sure how my boy Rowe will do against the Pies.

[Windigo]

Thoughts on having Shano B at F6 rather than Caffer.  ???

I just feel that Caff is way to dodgy to be starting and he is more of a bench option TBH. I think Shan should outscore Caff every week..

Thoughts?

[pinochio]

whats a better way to fund jpk > watson trade?

whitfield to jones
robbo to goldstien (bringing cox forward)
smith to berger (wanna see at least how he goes in one game i reckon, dont want to be chomping and changing r2 spot)


thoughts?

[essendon2]

Hey mate,

Who should I start out of Macaffer, Neade and Rowe?

Cheers

add Dwyer to that list !

[Master Q]

Thoughts on having Shano B at F6 rather than Caffer.  ???

I just feel that Caff is way to dodgy to be starting and he is more of a bench option TBH. I think Shan should outscore Caff every week..

Thoughts?

I agree that he's too dodgy to be starting but I'm not sure about Shano... If he's already in your team then start him but if you are going to trade him in then I'd consider it...

whats a better way to fund jpk > watson trade?

whitfield to jones
robbo to goldstien (bringing cox forward)
smith to berger (wanna see at least how he goes in one game i reckon, dont want to be chomping and changing r2 spot)


thoughts?

I'd say 1 or 2 (if you're against 3), probably 2 because you can wait a week for the rookies...

[Master Q]

Hey mate,

Who should I start out of Macaffer, Neade and Rowe?

Cheers

add Dwyer to that list !

Still Macaffer

*edit I think I might punt on Neade as a matter of fact  :-[

[hugebbq]

Rowe and Neade will start on field. Mac looking at that bench looks dodgy for the sub.

would the pies choose macaffer as sub over dwyer, seedsman?

[Master Q]

Rowe and Neade will start on field. Mac looking at that bench looks dodgy for the sub.

would the pies choose macaffer as sub over dwyer, seedsman?

I don't think so. I'm going with Neade, he's more risky but I can't see Macaffer pumping out those huge scores.

[hugebbq]

Neade it is

[hugebbq]

hang on, I only bought Neade in this week. Should I reverse and bring in dwyer instead?

[Andrew]

My worst spuds on the weekend were Toby Greene & Zac Smith. Do you think these trades are good?

Greene -> JJK (using DPP trading rule)
Zac Smith -> Kreuzer

Leaves me with 160k next week to go:

Dwyer -> Wines
McVeigh -> Mark Murphy


Good trades?

[bob321]

willing to give dangerfield another week so looking to trade out toby greene and get in viney
should i go whitfield > viney and greene > watson
or k.mitchell > viney and greene > s.mitchell

[Master Q]

hang on, I only bought Neade in this week. Should I reverse and bring in dwyer instead?

Errrr... Neade has better JS but if Dwyer manages to score well this week, and get named next week - he'll make a lot of moolah. I'd stick with Neade.