Karnezis or Kennedy (WC)?

[iliak]

Hey guys!
Should i stay with karnezis or find cash to upgrade to kennedy?
Worried about karnys score
cheers

[powersuperkents]

Karny, You'll make more cash off him and JJK won't score like that again, It was a one time score for him. It's like when Lindsay Thomas scored 160+ against Carlton and people jumped on him and he scored 60's for the rest of the season, it happens a lot one good score and people get deluded in fantasy of what they want to happen without thinking of the reality

JJK should only average a 70-76 there's just way more benefit in Karnezis

[Sweetness]

I would wait another week on that trade mate.
Brisbane got thumped on the weekend. I believe Karnezis should score a fair bit better this week.

Yes Kennedy scored well (and is now without LeCras), but I would re-evaluate after this round.
If Kennedy backs it up this week then consider. I myself have Karny and would be happy to downgrade a Robbo/Zorko (pending performance) to JJK and roll with both for a while.

[lolamusi]

False. JJK will most likely score like that again, but his average won't be that high. He'll probably average around 80

[Bill Manspeaker]

False. JJK will most likely score like that again, but his average won't be that high. He'll probably average around 80

yeah agreed. what's stopping him from kicking a bag against a shizen team?  he will also have down games though

[iliak]

cheers guys!
Appreciate the advice, might keep him for 1 or 2 more weeks.
:)

[lolamusi]

False. JJK will most likely score like that again, but his average won't be that high. He'll probably average around 80

yeah agreed. what's stopping him from kicking a bag against a shizen team?  he will also have down games though

yeah  ::)

[Sweetness]

Wonder if this trade becomes more of an option with Karnezis looking at a possible vest?......

[Jukes]

STOP CHASING POINTS BASED ON ONE WEEK

[Colliwobblers]

i would only do this if i knew karnezis was vested, and there is no way of knowing that, the risk is there but so is the risk of injury or a sudden onset of spuditis.

i'd stick with hi his preseason form was outstanding as was his 2012 season in the NEAFL.

kennedy can wait until next week anyway..

[Adamant]

JJK by a country mile IMO.

Still don't rate Karnezis and can't see him averaging past 70. JJK will be more inconsistent, but will be a safe 75-80.

[fertalong]

JJK by a country mile IMO.

Still don't rate Karnezis and can't see him averaging past 70. JJK will be more inconsistent, but will be a safe 75-80.

This is true, but if you alreayd have karny it's not worth trading him out for JJK.

[powersuperkents]

JJK by a country mile IMO.

Still don't rate Karnezis and can't see him averaging past 70. JJK will be more inconsistent, but will be a safe 75-80.

This is true, but if you alreayd have karny it's not worth trading him out for JJK.

"Still don't rate Karnezis and can't see him averaging past 70" can't agree with you more there. Everyone thought he'd average 80+ on the basis of his preseason. But that was always the second preference for choosing him. The first and everyone can agree was because in a position lacking rookies he was and most likely will be one of the biggest cash cows, he is a shining beacon, a glimmer of hope for a forsaken position with barely any good players.. Now I can't see anyone keeping JJK in their side because frankly that is a shower team, even if he is F6 by seasons end it's still pretty pathetic. Karnezis should bring in the same amount of money if not more than JJK so it's a matter of who you have. If you started JJK no point in downgrading to Karny, If you started Karny not point upgrading to JJK...

Your literally considering to do this

Karny -> JJK
JJK -> Stevie J etc./ Rookie
if Rookie
Moloney etc.-> Ablett etc.

when you can just go
Karny -> Stevie J etc./Rookie
if Rookie
Moloney etc.-> Ablett etc.

If your going for total points I can't see JJK scoring so far ahead of Karny to actually be worth the inconvenience... and you are only getting JJK as a cashcow? a purpose Karny could also serve (much better I might add because of the $50k you need to waste time freeing up to do the upgrade). If you are planning on picking JJK as a keeper I'm sorry I can't help anyone that lost...

Yes there are unlimited trades but that still doesn't mean you should throw them around illogically. What are you going to benefit? JJK isn't a premium or even a semi-premium, I rank him in the same boat as Karny and Karny got flogged by Bulldogs he should score better in an even game and JJK's score was a freak occurrence (why I think that? Until this week there has never been any dt hype for him... ever)which will most likely only happen one maybe two more times this season. He scored 2 100+ scores in 2011, 3 in 2010 barely 2 in 2009. I can't see him being more quality than Karny and also the fact Karny's cheaper makes me side with him

But mostly it's the fact you already have Karny in your team that makes this whole topic pointless!!!!

[Ricochet]

People jumping off Karny because he scored showerhouse in a team that got belted... Keep him fellas, he will do his job for you

[nrich102]

People jumping off Karny because he scored showerhouse in a team that got belted... Keep him fellas, he will do his job for you

+1