SC team very hard to beat...

[pie time]

Please give some feedback....

Backs
Enright, H.Shaw,fisher,hodge,kennelly,greenwood,schofield
emg- maguire and trengrove PA.

Mids
Ablett, mitchell,boyd,vince,martin,jetta SYD
emg- Barlow and shuey

Rucks
Jolly and warnock
emg- stanley and lobbe.

Forwards


Roo,browny,higgins,gia,tippett,dangerfield,ziebell.
emg-rockliff and gumbleton

[Rooey23]

Pretty nice team!

I would Maybe be a little concerned about having both Greenwood and Schofield in the starting line up, but Maguire gives some good back up. After the NAB Challenge game vs Carlton today he looks like he will be a starter in Round 1.


Not sure if Vince is good value considering the extra attention he will receive this year and Warnock as a starting Ruck is a worry.

Forward line is solid! Higgins in for a big year. 


Forward line is solid! Higgins in for a big year. 

[pie time]

Thanks for the feedback...last spot in defence and 2nd ruckman still up for grabs.....

[enzedder]

Solid team....like it...

Rucks are thin but looks like you've spent the $ wisely elsewhere

only query would be Schofield cause I don't know anything about him

[pie time]

Trying to find a player that not many people will have...i will find out more about Schofield tonight. ,Only young player at west coast. played well in 1st NAB cup game, but then again only played a young richmond side..

[pie time]

Made some changes. Hopefully for the last time..

Backs
Enright, H.Shaw,fisher,hodge,kennelly,greenwood,malceski
emg- maguire and waters.

Mids
Ablett, mitchell,boyd,vince,martin, shuey
emg- Barlow and banner

Rucks
Jolly and seaby
emg- warnock and skipper

Forwards


Roo,browny,higgins,gia,rockliff,dangerfield,ziebell.
emg-pods and gumbleton

[hespey]

me likey

back line 10/10

mid 9/10 (starting two rookies)

ruck 8/10 (no sandilands.. but jolly seems good for colly, and seaby as a number 1 ruckman for the 2nd best stopping side in the league, you have chosen wisely)

forward 7/10 (ziebell.. injury concerns, disposal poor, tagger. gia.. inconsistent. gumbleton.. no. wait till he strings a couple of decent games together and trade for him. dont start with him)



overall 8.5/10.

you should be flattered.  :-*

[pie time]

thanks for the feedback....Will watch Gumbleton up till round 1. Ziebell or medhurst?????

[pie time]

Little worried with forward line - pls give advise.

Backs
Enright, H.Shaw,Goddard,hodge,kennelly,malceski,Maguire
emg- Waters and trengrove PA.

Mids
Ablett, mitchell,boyd,Higgins,martin,Shuey
emg- Barlow and Banner

Rucks
Jolly and Seaby
emg- Skipper and lobbe.

Forwards


Roo,browny,Tippett,Betts,Dangerfield,Medhurst,ziebell.
emg-Pods and gumbleton

[c4v3m4n]

In regards to Gumbleton, I watched him play today in the NAB Challenge game against Richmond and I was really impressed. Was one of the best players for the day.

If his body can hold up, he'll be a great buy.

[MC]

Need to find a replacement for Fisher. He came off injured in tonight's game.

[pie time]

been replaced by goddard as per last side posted