Rich+Moloney vs JPK+Rookie

[Bones Bombers]

Rookie would be Mitchell or Kent or Jones :-\
Moloney has good JS and I like him and Rich as players.
JPK is very good but hasn't been at the top level for long.
Give me some opinions/predictions please!

[GoLions]

I'd go Rich and Moloney, although I may be a tad bias  ::)

My guess on averages is Rich(95) + Moloney(90) =185
JPK(105) + Rookie(65) = 170

Hopefully my predictions are close to being accurate...

[Colliwobblers]

think all those players make better SC players than DT players.  But I would go with JPK, with the trades available you can sideways him to the best performing mid when he drops off as his draw gets harder, but until he does drop off you score great.

Rich and Moloney not sure on, moloney a good cash cow but will rich get the sheer number to be a gun in DT - i doubt it with the #1 tag every week....

his ball use being so good means what he does get will score well for him in SC but for DT i just question if he can rack up the sheer numbers....?

[Bones Bombers]

Added a poll. First time this old blokes done that, was easy!

[Bones Bombers]

I'd go Rich and Moloney, although I may be a tad bias  ::)

My guess on averages is Rich(95) + Moloney(90) =185
JPK(105) + Rookie(65) = 170

Cheers! I think Rich could push to 100 and Moloney around 90.
Rich is very fit and firing after a great preseason. Main worry is the tag but don't forget Rocky. Does he get tagged in the mids?

[Colliwobblers]

I'd go Rich and Moloney, although I may be a tad bias  ::)

My guess on averages is Rich(95) + Moloney(90) =185
JPK(105) + Rookie(65) = 170

Cheers! I think Rich could push to 100 and Moloney around 90.
Rich is very fit and firing after a great preseason. Main worry is the tag but don't forget Rocky. Does he get tagged in the mids?

Black was always tagged first, Rich second. That will change this season, Rich #1 100%, for clarification ask Ringo :) but i'm right

[Bones Bombers]

With the extra trades I'm very tempted.
Can always downgrade to whichever cheapie is going to make a wad of cash and then upgrade soon after.

[GoLions]

I'd go Rich and Moloney, although I may be a tad bias  ::)

My guess on averages is Rich(95) + Moloney(90) =185
JPK(105) + Rookie(65) = 170

Cheers! I think Rich could push to 100 and Moloney around 90.
Rich is very fit and firing after a great preseason. Main worry is the tag but don't forget Rocky. Does he get tagged in the mids?

Black was always tagged first, Rich second. That will change this season, Rich #1 100%, for clarification ask Ringo :) but i'm right

I agree Rich will get tagged a lot more, but I don't think it will happen every week, and he should also learn to handle it a lot better.

[Jukes]

Rich 93, Moloney 84
vs
JPK 106, Mitchell 72

I'd edge towards JPK and Mitchell, especially with that start.

[Bones Bombers]

Rich 93, Moloney 84
vs
JPK 106, Mitchell 72

I'd edge towards JPK and Mitchell, especially with that start.

Was waiting for the Jukes Coefficient!
Interested to know if you think the 72 from Mitchell would be every week?

[Jukes]

Every week. People saying he'll be sub, lucky to play etc are fools.

He was the best player in the whole WAFL last season. Immense in every game, is a superstar and is in their top 5 mids imo.

Will play as many games as possible (i.e. when not injured/suspended) and will accumulate decent scores.

[yorgis]

not convinced that rich will always cop the tag. 2 other r's that warrant it , rocky and redders

[Bones Bombers]

Oops forgot to mention that the JPK option leaves 100k in the bank and he could actually be anyone.
Chose him because of the rd12 bye.
Don't want to start Beams and would rather see Cotch, Lids and Murph before I decide.
Already have Ablett, Swan, Pendles and Watson.
Who would you guys choose?

[Toga]

Oops forgot to mention that the JPK option leaves 100k in the bank and he could actually be anyone.
Chose him because of the rd12 bye.
Don't want to start Beams and would rather see Cotch, Lids and Murph before I decide.
Already have Ablett, Swan, Pendles and Watson.
Who would you guys choose?

I'd probably go with one of Cotch/Lids/Murphy actually... Murphy has a huge average against his firs two opponents and a huge average at the MCG where he plays those two opponents... Should start the season with a bang... Also reckon Cotch will be a DT monster this year with more help inside from Dusty and co... ;)

[Bones Bombers]

Oops forgot to mention that the JPK option leaves 100k in the bank and he could actually be anyone.
Chose him because of the rd12 bye.
Don't want to start Beams and would rather see Cotch, Lids and Murph before I decide.
Already have Ablett, Swan, Pendles and Watson.
Who would you guys choose?

I'd probably go with one of Cotch/Lids/Murphy actually... Murphy has a huge average against his firs two opponents and a huge average at the MCG where he plays those two opponents... Should start the season with a bang... Also reckon Cotch will be a DT monster this year with more help inside from Dusty and co... ;)

Those bloody taggers are what's worrying me with those guys.