Wines/Stevens + Frost v M.Jones + Pittard

[Jroo]

Which combo should I pick?
I'm a big fan of Wines and Stevens, but I'm not sure if it's worth downgrading Pittard to Frost for one of them though.
I'll chuck you a cheer if you can help me out. I'm

[GraysFan]

Wines will outscore Jones... but not by too much.. both also have good js.. where as pittard should smash frost// also frost has no js and will be out of the side in 1-2 week when collingwood regains its defenders from injury

[hawkers65]

This is how i see it JROO

Wines/Stevens (70) + Frost (55) = 125
and
Jones (65) + Pittard (65) = 130

IMO I'd go option 2, although i love Wines, IMO Frost will average 55 at best, doesn't seem to rack it up much.

[jmoynihan9]

Wines and Stevens the best picks of the lot and will average more compared to Jones. But will the amount that they average more be more than that of Pittard compared to Frost?
I'd say this:
Wines/Stevens 75-85(Lets say 80) + Frost 55 = 135
Jones 65-75 + Pittard 65-75 = 140
Points wise I would say the second two and they will score reasonably well and both mature age so should have good job security in two developing teams.
In the first selection, out of everyone Wines and Stevens easily the best job security and scoring potential but Frost scoring potential is easily the lowest and his job security scratchy compared to the rest but may get a few games as he would've been upgraded for a reason.
I will be honest i know very little about Frost but yeh thats my take on your situation and I would go with Jones and Pittard! Hope I was of some help

[Marstar]

Got them all except *J*F*<--- Snow Flakes :P

[Jroo]

Thanks for the responses.
Instead of Frost I could get Docherty, if I downgrade Rowe/Neade to Dwyer

[hawkers65]

Thanks for the responses.
Instead of Frost I could get Docherty, if I downgrade Rowe/Neade to Dwyer

I don't really like Docherty's JS either, i assume your running the 3 premo backs? I've been running this for a while and the only rookies ive been comfortable with are: Brown, Goodes, Pittard, Stevensen and Terlich.

[Marstar]

I don't really like Docherty's JS either, i assume your running the 3 premo backs? I've been running this for a while and the only rookies ive been comfortable with are: Brown, Goodes, Pittard, Stevensen and Terlich.

+1