Another Forward Poll

Started by lowry, March 25, 2013, 09:21:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Wright has gone so who to get as F5?

DMartin $473k - currently in my team
20 (52.6%)
Robinson $474 - POD
4 (10.5%)
Blair $473
1 (2.6%)
Watts - $460 - good preseason
6 (15.8%)
Monfries $356 - still injured?
2 (5.3%)
Petterd $240k
1 (2.6%)
Varcoe $268
0 (0%)
Other?
4 (10.5%)

Total Members Voted: 1

lowry

Is there any other priced $475  or below? (already have Karnezis)

tor01doc

Hard to gauge what you're after.

Comparing apples and oranges?  ???

Big Mac

DMartin - Has the ability to end the year as the number 1 forward, but seems to drift in and out of the game most of the time.
Robinson - Good pick, should improve and become a solid premium
Blair - Can't see him improving
Watts - Doesn't know how to use his body
Monfries - Injured and low ceiling
Petterd - Low ceiling
Varcoe - Popular pick but can't really see him improving from 70

Honestly I'd have to choose from Martin and Robinson, probably leaning towards Martin at the moment. Another pick would be Kennedy, although he is a key forward so will score inconsistently.

Samm79

Colin Sylvia is a risky stepping stone to Buddy, has a high ceiling but is high risk.

Another alternative, if looking for a value F6 may be Bruest? Can average 95 and is less risky than Sylvia.

Hope this give you something to ponder  ;)

lowry

thanks guys for your efforts! @sam you have made my mind explode!!  :D

My forward line currently is Buddy, Cox, Bartel, Rockliff, .........., Karnezis (Maccaffer, Neade)

Samm79

No worries! That is anstrong forward line, JJK would have fitted in there nicely...

Another option is to find some $$ elsewhere and get Zorko. Have no issue with getting an expensive second year player with his attributes. Stevie J is another option and I think he's underpriced and an easy VC loophole for this round. This may give you too stronger forward line and too weaker other lines but unless you consider any of these options likely hood of becoming a keeper to be greater than 80% you should probably go back to the drawing board instead of going for an option you're not entirely happy with!

Sorry if this makes your head hurt further! ;)

Ricochet

DMart for me. Has gone close to 100 before and should go 100+ this year

Cruiseon


For an additional $10k I'm thinking of Jack Reiwoldt ahead of those mentioned below.

Outside of BUddy he is probably the only other genuine contender for the Coleman so I'm surprised he has been largely overlooked for Martin.

Thoughts?

EZA100

watts did look good in his practice match 2 weeks ago to scoring 164 points if you didn't know and has that dpp link which is useful. But if riewoldt improves from last year he will be a good buy.