The Official Matthew Boyd Replacement Thread

[Ziplock]

I've gone with Jelwood.  8)

Destroys Hawks, North & Power in his first 5: (118, 115 & 124) And he will be a keeper unlike (IMO) Kennedy.  ;)

Always finds a way to get injured, concussed, suspended, or rested. Will never play 22 games no Geelong premo does.

Played 22 in 2009  :P

So, 17% of his career :P

[m_zulian]

Anyone like Sam Mitchell as a replacement for Boyd!

Mitchell has averaged 112 and 102 last two years and has averaged at least 100 the past 4 years

[m_zulian]

I was tossing up between Deledio and Mitchell.
I try to pick premium midfielders that have averaged over 100 for at least two years.
last year was the first year Deledio has averaged over 100. There is talk Newman will be spending more time in the midfield. Also, Hardwick has talked up Martin. This may affect deledios' scores.
I have chosen Mitchell.
My premium mids are Swan, Ablett, Pendlebury, Redden and Mitchell

[Toga]

I was tossing up between Deledio and Mitchell.
I try to pick premium midfielders that have averaged over 100 for at least two years.
last year was the first year Deledio has averaged over 100. There is talk Newman will be spending more time in the midfield. Also, Hardwick has talked up Martin. This may affect deledios' scores.
I have chosen Mitchell.
My premium mids are Swan, Ablett, Pendlebury, Redden and Mitchell

Martin in the middle will only help turn Deledio and Cotchin turn into DT monsters!!

If Dusty plays inside, Lids and Cotch should be seeing a lot more of the ball being fed to them by Dusty so I reckon it'll just improve their scores, definitely won't harm them!

[Windigo]

Anyone like Sam Mitchell as a replacement for Boyd!

Mitchell has averaged 112 and 102 last two years and has averaged at least 100 the past 4 years

More upside in Selwood surely? 4 years of 100+ and is 24 compared 30+....

[Holz]

I was tossing up between Deledio and Mitchell.
I try to pick premium midfielders that have averaged over 100 for at least two years.
last year was the first year Deledio has averaged over 100. There is talk Newman will be spending more time in the midfield. Also, Hardwick has talked up Martin. This may affect deledios' scores.
I have chosen Mitchell.
My premium mids are Swan, Ablett, Pendlebury, Redden and Mitchell

Lids went from high 90s to 110 because he changed his role to be a midfielder. He will not go down back and he was an elite DT backman  for many years and now simply he is an elite DT midfielder. Im taking him as a guy with a history of being an elite DT player.

[nrich102]

I got lids