Snap Reaction?

Started by billnats, March 24, 2013, 01:44:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

billnats

Was thinking about this before the first round begun and will cost me two trades now. Worth it?
Current - Dangerfield, Johnson, McCaffer (Spanger)
Possible change - Mundy, Martin, Kennedy (McCaffer)

colmullet

Isn't that 3 trades? i would wait at least another week and Danger will come good

shaker

Gross overreaction we are 2 games into the season to think that you would turf danger after 1 game is insane.

billnats

It's two trades. Martin and Johnson haven't played yet.
My thinking on average:
Danger 120 + McCaffer 70= 190
Mundy 110 + Kennedy 100 = 210

Plus no real forward rookies on bench as cover!

colmullet

Kennedy wont average 100 just because he scored 100 last night, your over reacting, sit tight

bottlemart

No.  Do not trade. 

Massive over reaction after one game. 

Keep the players you have selected.  You picked them for a reason, so keep the faith.  Plenty of time for trading during the next 23 weeks.

Hippo

I'd be surprised if Kennedy avg 100

And I think you can pump mundys up by 5

billnats

Fair points... It was mainly because I wanted Mundy but went against him at M5 for Swallow. Wouldn't know what to do with the extra 100K though!

xumtinglong

Overreaction. But option 2 looks alot safer
McCaffer might get the vest
Johnson will explode (scores/temper) so you are not sure what's going to happen
Mundy, Martin, Kennedy should give you a consistent score every week around their averages

juzztheball

Kennedy got 120 odd first game last year and look how his season ended, including his games he wasn't affected by injury. He's a kpp, they're all basically hit or miss. He hit last night, and you're basically wanting to change you're whole forward line? Please

Mat0369

Just trade a forward every week to whomever is playing on Zac Dawson  ::)

Free Kick

Quote from: bottlemart on March 24, 2013, 02:05:06 PM
No.  Do not trade. 

Massive over reaction after one game. 

Keep the players you have selected.  You picked them for a reason, so keep the faith.  Plenty of time for trading during the next 23 weeks.

Solid Advice 8)

BB67th

Quote from: Free Kick on March 24, 2013, 04:03:33 PM
Quote from: bottlemart on March 24, 2013, 02:05:06 PM
No.  Do not trade. 

Massive over reaction after one game. 

Keep the players you have selected.  You picked them for a reason, so keep the faith.  Plenty of time for trading during the next 23 weeks.

Solid Advice 8)
+1 This happens every year with people thinking they should sideways trade all their players after 1 round. It's not very often that everyone of your players does great first round. Give it time, a season is a long time.

ronl

True.  "One swallow dost not a summer make." Or something like that. 

Marstar

Quote from: ronl on March 24, 2013, 05:36:11 PM
True.  "One swallow dost not a summer make." Or something like that.

Unless you're 16 ;)