how we lookin?

Started by flyupup, March 23, 2013, 07:43:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

flyupup

Team 1.

Backs:  goddard, gibbs, shaw, goodes, pittard, stevenson, (terlich, colquhoun)

Midfield:  ablett, swan, pendles, watson, cotchin, lucas, omeara, viney, (mitchell, kommer)

Rucks:  cox, jacobs (blicavs, currie)

Forwards:  franklin, rockliff, zorko, karnezis, macaffer, neade, (lee, rowe)

$1,600 left.


Team 2.

Backs:  goddard, gibbs, shaw, armstrong, pittard, stevenson, (terlich, goodes)

Midfield:  ablett, swan, pendles, watson, vlastuin, lucas, omeara, viney, (mitchell, kommer)

Rucks:  cox, jacobs (blicavs, currie)

Forwards:  franklin, rockliff, zorko, karnezis, macaffer, varcoe, (neade, rowe)

$176,600 left.


Stuck between these 2 teams, only going for my league win for now and see how we go....
Team 2 feels more balanced with a nice bit of cash left over.

Would really like some feedback and opinions on how and where I could fix up and strengthen these squads, thanks.






Carn

#1
Team 1 is strong in all areas but the fwd line. I would not start neade, I was worried about starting macaffer.
Team 2 is better. I wouldn't start vlastun in mids look at jones or wines for me if they get named.
RMT please:
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74258.0.html

johnnytheboy1

Team 2 is probably better as it has an even balance you made the wrong choice with Varcoe should have gone with Josh Kennedy. Vlastuin is the only worry apart from hat team 2 is slightly better but i would use up some of that money you have sitting around.

millencholy

Team 2 for mine, though I would be concerned with your FWD line in either, I think you will struggle with only 3 A graders in there, the FWDs are the hardest line this year, I would be putting in someone like Martin/Bartel etc so you arent left short

sammy123

both teams are great. Id go 1. Both are 9/10. Like the 5 prem mid

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74834.0.html

flyupup

Thanks for the responses guys....

Started this year a bit late and rushed, just realized I could have had Josh Kennedy in the fwds instead of Macaffer.
Ah well, we got 30 trades this year?, I think I will keep team 2 and bring in Kennedy after round 1 with the left over cash.