The combo to decide Jayman's team

[Jay]

THIS POLL WILL DECIDE MY TEAM

Please help me out guys. A vote and maybe a little explanation would be super.

P.S For option 2 I could go Robbo or Hawkins instead of Dusty?

[Jay]

Interesting start to the votes.

JPK, Mundy, Martin off to early lead :)

[Doggoneit]

the way I see it - which risk are you prepared to take

1 - risk an injury prone berger with limited preseason but will pump out at least 100 avg and increase in value by $200k+

2 - take the risk that dusty will significantly increase his output, hoping choco's got his head right. uproven at consistently giving premium output but has the potential to get there.
IMO Mundy is no risk and good value.

[tor01doc]

JPK is every bit as good as JPK - so that's easy.


Selwood is better than Mundy.

Both Leue and Martin are risky but Leue is a lot cheaper.

[Jay]

JPK is every bit as good as JPK - so that's easy.


Selwood is better than Mundy.

Both Leue and Martin are risky but Leue is a lot cheaper.

Yeah I messed up - both JPKs have been erased

Mundy + Martin
vs.
Selwood + Leuey

[Jay]

Look, it's getting close now!

Just if you were wondering, I get Martin by putting Cox into the rucks

[Marstar]

Ideally Selwood and Leue would be a much better option (though getting the cash for Mundy(Fyfe) seems like the most recommended move). But right now? Mundy and Martin ONLY because Leue is too much of a headache (and heartache) option at the moment.

You can always downgrade to Leue and bank the cash b4 a price-rise.  You can always do the the same with Martin if he stinks it up.

What i wouldn't risk is having to find a replacement for Leue week 2-3 (likely costing you 2 trades to upgrade him to a premo by downgrading an average performing premo in another line back down).

Hope that helps J.

[nrich102]

Which Martin is it?

[Patriot Manhattan]

Which Martin is it?

Dustin.

Dustin + Mundy for me. I think we can pencil David in for 115 this year which will at the very least be pushing Bunnings..& I'd trust Martin a lot more than I would trust Leu.

[nrich102]

Which Martin is it?

Dustin.

Dustin + Mundy for me. I think we can pencil David in for 115 this year which will at the very least be pushing Bunnings..& I'd trust Martin a lot more than I would trust Leu.

Thanks, Would have to be Mundy and Martin, but Luey is a gun  ???

[Patriot Manhattan]

Which Martin is it?

Dustin.

Dustin + Mundy for me. I think we can pencil David in for 115 this year which will at the very least be pushing Bunnings..& I'd trust Martin a lot more than I would trust Leu.

Thanks, Would have to be Mundy and Martin, but Luey is a gun  ???

For sure he is, but his body will fail again eventually and I wouldn't want to have him around when it does.
It's Higgins all over again - if only mentality could (will) catch people out..