Bragging Rights - Who will get it right.

[Marstar]

Before we get deep into R1 and beyond, lets see who's advice preseason has/will pay off. Below is a list of some of the most popular Player A v Player B polls/discussion that have been tossed up preseason. If you are willing to back yourself here is the chance to put them all together. Maybe next year, or even during the season, you'll be remembered that little more and your words of wisdom with hold some persuasion. So in bold is the recommendation you would make on the choice presented and in (brackets) who you are would recommend (or take in your own team) in that same bracket:

Mundy vs Fyfe
Danger vs Cotchin (Deledio)
Rockliff vs Zorko
Duffield vs Hartlett vs Hanley (but took the other 2 :P)
Bartel vs Walker (Stevie.J)

And finally the most popular mid-price forwards (note there are 2-3 more that got far less mentions/questions) - pick 3

LeCras vs JJK vs Kennedy vs Varcoe vs Karnezis vs Byrnes (Currently only have Karnezis and am very interested in Harper and Petterd).

[GoLions]

Except for the mid-pricers, where I have only recommended Karnezis, the rest is all the exact same for me.
Oh, and I ended up taking the Duffman  :)

[Footyrulz]

very interesting topic!

i took:

Mundy
Priddis instead of cotchin or danger
Rocky
Duffman
neither
Karnezis only

[LF]

Mundy vs Fyfe     Rich
Danger vs Cotchin  Jack/Swallow
Rockliff vs Zorko  Both
Duffield vs Hartlett vs Hanley  Hibberd
Bartel vs Walker Bartel

Karnezis,LeCras and JJK

[Marstar]

Good start :D

Need some of the 3 and 4 star Generals who are vocal to put it on the line :P

e.g. Tbag backed Danger (regardless of the one off game) and Quinny is all over Cotchin ....

MTTY? Jayman? JROO? Colliwob? Tor-doc? Ringo? :P

[colmullet]

Mundy/Hanneberry
Danger
Rocky
Duffield
Walker
JJK,Karnezis,Byrnes

people jumped off byrnes but he only needs a few decent games to gain $100K+ at his price and has great JS

[nostradamus]

Mundy vs Fyfe ......niether
Danger vs Cotchin.....niether
Rockliff vs Zorko......Both
Duffman vs Hartlett ....niether
Bartel vs Walker ....niether
Mid price fwds listed.....Karnezis

[Marstar]

Mundy vs Fyfe ......niether
Danger vs Cotchin.....niether
Rockliff vs Zorko......Both
Duffman vs Hartlett ....niether
Bartel vs Walker ....niether
Mid price fwds listed.....Karnezis

Come on ... with a name like that surely you'll back yourself to recommend an alternative :P That is the whole point of the thread. Back yourself for some good advice :)

Also you don't have to back Mundy or Fyfe either, but surely you have an opinion on who you think will take the honours round 23.

[KoopKicka]

Fyfe
neither - Deledio
Both - ROcky slightly more
Neither until Hartlett strings more than 8 games together - Hanley
Bartel - but took Martin due to cash
Kazneris, Harper and JJK

[MTTY]

For me:

Mundy

Cotchin (Deledio - I have Deledio)

Zorko (Both - I have both)

Duffield (I have Duffield)

Bartel (Pavlich)

Pick 3 - Karnezis, LeCras, JJK (I have Karnezis)

[the captain]

Mundy
Cotchin
Zorko
Hartlett
Walker
LeCras, Varcoe, Karnezis

[KoopKicka]

Can you put Harper in the Midpriced Forwards as well?

[Marstar]

Can you put Harper in the Midpriced Forwards as well?

Just give advice on which 3 from those named, for those ppl who are 'only' considering them. Then add "I've picked Harper instead" :)

[tbagrocks]

Bulldust! The last two weeks the Dangerman has been heavily favoured over Cotchin!

I will expect Cotch to still score below the 63 ;)

[quinny88]

Bulldust! The last two weeks the Dangerman has been heavily favoured over Cotchin!

I will expect Cotch to still score below the 63 ;)

Cotch would score more than 63 even if he had his hands tied behind his back