Cotchin vs Deledio

[vrama]

Stats to consider:
Cotchin in 2012 --> 110.7 ave, 17 x 100's, 6 x 120's, 5 x >100

Deledio in 2012 --> 110.4 ave, 17 x 100's, 6 x 120's, 5 x >100

Other facts to consider:

More potential for Cotchin to improve perhaps, Cotchin gets #1 tag each week, Cotchin perhaps gets tagged harder this year on the back of his form last year, Deledio is still only 25 years old.

[bowyanger]

Mate good topic

Ive actually been pondering this myself, Lids would be a good POD it seems

Ive got Cotch on my radar but Im considering Lids, the bloke is super fit and quick. Has a few more pre seasons under his belt, is the right age and I would assume would be a truckload harder to tackle than Cotch because of his pre seasons


If he was in a better side everyone would be raving about him IMO.

Richmond are starting to get some experience into their players, Hardwicks game plan sinking in, along with Choccos influence / knowledge only has to make them a better side all round = Year of Lids domination?

With Houli, Newman and co getting better down back, hopefully it turns into more / permanent mid time for Lids.

Big gamble but I cant see Lids spudding it up either. He is used to the hard tag and all the focus as he was the only player they had 2 years ago


Another Richmond player Ive been slightly considering as well is Nahas

[Hagebear]

U should move this to the "players and trades" boards. U'll get a lot more feedback. But it's Cotchin for me. Lids had a massive year last year but I can't see any improvement in his scoring. I think that's a s good as it gets for him, whereas I still think Cotchin has a lot of improvement left in him. I think they will both get tagged as much as the other.