Need help... pick two.

Started by LaHug, March 21, 2013, 09:25:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Pick two..

Cotchin
5 (62.5%)
Deledio
11 (137.5%)
Pendlebury
19 (237.5%)
Dangerfield
2 (25%)
Keep Cotch, Lids, Pendles and miss out on Wines and Macaffer
3 (37.5%)

Total Members Voted: 8

LaHug

Had to downgrade one of Cotchin, Deledio, and Pendlebury to Fyfe so that I could afford Wines and Macaffer.
Which two should I keep?
Or should I just not bother with Wines and Macaffer...?

Aaron8

i would keep Pendles and Lids.
Wines is a must have this year imo will slot straight into Port's midfield, And with not many fwd rooks Caf looks the only one that will see some game time so think you need the both of them really

Adamant


LaHug

Why not Cotch? I'd have thought he was the best choice, particularly as his last two against the Blues are 118 and 120...

Adamant

Quote from: LaHug on March 21, 2013, 09:37:57 PM
Why not Cotch? I'd have thought he was the best choice, particularly as his last two against the Blues are 118 and 120...

Well, Pendles is a must have. Played half a year on a broken leg, yet still averaged 110 (the same as Cotch). He's at least 6 points underpriced as he averaged 116 in 2011 and I think he'll push the 120 mark this year. He'll at least go 115+.

Lids vs Cotch is just personal preference. I prefer Lids' for safety.

Aaron8

Quote from: LaHug on March 21, 2013, 09:37:57 PM
Why not Cotch? I'd have thought he was the best choice, particularly as his last two against the Blues are 118 and 120...

I'm wary of players that have breakout seasons Dangerfield also. Just think they will both be tagged pretty heavily this year. At least with Lids you know what your gonna get 100+ scores on a regular basis and hasn't missed a game in like 5-6 years easy choice.

tbagrocks

oh good, the Dangerman is still unique 8)

LaHug

Alternatively, I could go Bartel to Lecras and keep all three?
Is that a better choice?

Adamant

Quote from: LaHug on March 21, 2013, 10:01:18 PM
Alternatively, I could go Bartel to Lecras and keep all three?
Is that a better choice?

Nah, don't go there. Bartel will be a top 6-10 forward easy and he loves playing the Hawks. Should smash out a big one in round 1.

Lecca is good value, but he won't be a keeper and is far too expensive to be a cash cow.

LaHug

Basically, I have to choose between Bartel, all three mids, or a Belly/Kreuz ruck combo.
If I don't get Bartel, I get LeCras. If I don't get all three mids, one becomes Fyfe. If I don't get the ruck combo, it's Belly or Kreuz and Longer.
I have no idea what to do...

powersuperkents

Quote from: tbagrocks on March 21, 2013, 09:52:56 PM
oh good, the Dangerman is still unique 8)
That's because he's not that good  :P