Last Day, Final Team Selection... pretty much perfect lineup...

Started by Typhnn, March 21, 2013, 11:36:00 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Typhnn

Dropped Taylor in Def, and dropped Goldstein/Bellchambers from Ruck.... 

Bought in Watson/Maric/Rowe/Brown

So i added another prem to the mid but lost a few elsewhere, not 100% set but it does make Moloney M5 now....

Other option is drop Moloney/Lucas and bring in Fyfe/Rookie

Still have $94k leftover...

Cheers

B: Goddard, Gibbs, Heppell
B: Goodes, Pittard, Terlich
Bench: Brown, Steveson

M: Ablett, Swan, Watson, JKennedy(Syd)
M: Moloney, Lcas, Mitchell, O'Meara
Bench: Crouch, Viney

R: Maric, Blicavs
Bench: Rowe, Currie

F: Franklin, Cox, Zorko
F: Bartel, JKennedy(Eagles), Karnezis
Bench: Macaffer, Neade

9.5/10 :)

kilbluff1985

i'd say more like 7//10

if your going with 1 premo ruck your forwards need to be stronger incase you have to move Cox into the rucks

Typhnn

Fwd's are pretty strong... besides Pav, who else could you add in there...!?

kilbluff1985

Quote from: Typhnn on March 21, 2013, 11:46:23 AM
Fwd's are pretty strong... besides Pav, who else could you add in there...!?

i'd want to upgrade Kennedy to Rockliff/Robinson i'd downgrade Lucas to a rookie to do it

Typhnn

Rockliff in my team would mean 3 brisbane midfielders... and i don't trust brisbane or Rockliff to perform...

Robinson is too hit and miss for his price tag, and with new coach at Carlton Lucas seems to be a fav for the midfield possie...   just like Scotland can't even get a game anymore...??

Bigger risk running with Rockliff/Robinson in cash loss, than Sticking with kennedy and the eagles draw in first part of the season...!!


kilbluff1985

dude i'm saying if you need to move Cox into the rucks which is very likely your forwards will be very weak it will look like this if you have to use Cox as a ruck

F: Franklin, Rowe, Zorko
F: Bartel, JKennedy(Eagles), Karnezis
Bench: Macaffer, Neade

Kennedy wont average very high at all

Typhnn

I understand that, but a lot more people are running with same or less prem Fwds than i with cox in forward line

And by your own omission i should be running with 5 premiums in my fwd just to cover R2...!? seems excessive...

Last yr Giles as R2 was a great pickup...  it can still work this year with Blicavs, Currie, Rowe, etc...

ubeaut

Quote from: Typhnn on March 21, 2013, 12:53:50 PM
I understand that, but a lot more people are running with same or less prem Fwds than i with cox in forward line

And by your own omission i should be running with 5 premiums in my fwd just to cover R2...!? seems excessive...

Last yr Giles as R2 was a great pickup...  it can still work this year with Blicavs, Currie, Rowe, etc...
Mate Currei,Rowe etc are hardly Giles. I have same ruck set up as u but my fwds are Cox,Bartel,Pavlich,Zorko,Varcoe,Knights. Byrnes is on the bench (or maccaffer) if Cox has to ruck. (which he will).

I have already advised someone else to downgrade Lucas. I would do that too.