Brownlow Votes

[specky92]

3. Colyer
2. Melksham
1. Giles

?

[kilbluff1985]

Round 17

North Melbourne vs Carlton

3 Votes = K. Simpson
2 Votes = L. Henderson
1 Votes = E. Curnow

Essendon vs GWS

3 Votes = J. Melksham
2 Votes = B. Stanton
1 Votes = T. Colyer

Hawthorn vs Bulldogs

3 Votes = I Smith
2 Votes = R. Griffin
1 Votes = J. Lewis

Gold Coast vs Collingwood

3 Votes = G. Ablett
2 Votes = J. O'Meara
1 Votes = D. Beams

Melbourne vs Brisbane

3 Votes = T. Rockliff
2 Votes = J. Redden
1 Votes = P. Hanley

St Kilda vs Port Adelaide

3 Votes = L. Montagna
2 Votes = M. Lobbe
1 Votes = C. Wingard

not done ladder yet, will see what people think because Carlton, Essendon, Saints games were extremely hard to give votes for

[quinny88]

Agree kb, some Of these games have been near impossible. I would say the 5 best players on the ground last night were saints players but its not logical for all votes to go their way in a loosing side.

I think Coony was better than Griffin yesterday. Lewis was bog ahead of smith.
Would Lindsay Thomas atleast get 1 vote with a 6 goal game?
I thought colyer was bog for essendon.

Very tough round so far though

[specky92]

Colyer had 7 scoring involvements out of 18 goals... :P

[kilbluff1985]

Yeah I'll give Colyer the 3 I think

So would you just straight swap Cooney with Griff ?

Thomas only earnt like 2 or 3 of those goals rest were very cheap and he did like nothing else in the game he might get votes but not from me lol

Will give Lewis the 3 to

Thanks guys really appreciate the help

[Toga]

Yeah Cooney was very good I wouldn't be surprised if he polled, maybe instead of Griff as you say!

As for today's Richmond vs Fremantle, I'd say:

3. Cotchin
2. Rance
1. Riewoldt

I know Riewoldt might surprise, but he kicked some clutch goals so wouldn't be surprised if he polled... Otherwise Mzungu might sneak in for 1 vote seeing as he single-handedly kept them in the game in the 3rd...

[kilbluff1985]

Round 17

North Melbourne vs Carlton

3 Votes = K. Simpson
2 Votes = L. Henderson
1 Votes = E. Curnow

Essendon vs GWS

3 Votes = T. Colyer
2 Votes = J. Melksham
1 Votes = B. Stanton

Hawthorn vs Bulldogs

3 Votes = J. Lewis
2 Votes = A. Cooney
1 Votes = I. Smith

Gold Coast vs Collingwood

3 Votes = G. Ablett
2 Votes = J. O'Meara
1 Votes = D. Beams

Melbourne vs Brisbane

3 Votes = T. Rockliff
2 Votes = J. Redden
1 Votes = P. Hanley

St Kilda vs Port Adelaide

3 Votes = L. Montagna
2 Votes = M. Lobbe
1 Votes = C. Wingard

Richmond vs Fremantle

3 Votes = T. Cotchin
2 Votes = A. Rance
1 Votes = J. Riewoldt

Adelaide vs Geelong

3 Votes = R. Henderson
2 Votes = J. Selwood
1 Votes = R. Douglas

West Coast vs Sydney

3 Votes = D. Hannebery
2 Votes = K. Jack
1 Votes = J. P Kennedy

[Justin Bieber]

Jroo was ordinary. Would think Dan Jackson or soneone else played better.

[Ricochet]

3. Ablett
2. Ablett
1. Ablett

Seems about right

[Toga]

Jroo was ordinary. Would think Dan Jackson or soneone else played better.

He was for most of the game but he kicked a couple of clutch goals in the last quarter that put away Freo's advances - reckon they would stick in the umpire's minds...

[Rusty00]

Round 17
St Kilda vs Port Adelaide

3 Votes = L. Montagna
2 Votes = M. Lobbe
1 Votes = C. Wingard

Jack Steven might find his way into the votes with that amazing last quarter.

[kilbluff1985]

Hard to give votes to everyone

[Rusty00]

Hard to give votes to everyone

Yeah I know, wasn't a criticism, just an observation. You are doing a much better job than I would  ;)

[kilbluff1985]

thanks appreciate it

think i read your comment when i just woke up i'm not a morning person lol

[strikes91]

dude, berger was by far the best player in the lions v melb match