Brownlow Votes

[kilbluff1985]

Hawthorn vs Melbourne

3 Votes = B. Sewell
2 Votes = L. Breust
1 Votes = J. Lewis

North Melbourne vs St Kilda

3 Votes = B. Harvey
2 Votes = D. Petrie
1 Votes = A. Mullet

[Ziplock]

well, giles had 29 hit outs, so it wasn't like he dominated the ruck... all it shows is that there were a ton of stoppages.

haha, kk, I'll try to remember- round 10 GWS vs Carlton, Ward polling :P

[kilbluff1985]

no worries i shouldn't forget i have a good memory Kreuz might not get votes but pretty sure Ward wont

[kilbluff1985]

3 Votes = B. Deledio
2 Votes = N. Vlastuin
1 Votes = M. White

was going give Vlastuin the votes but figure Deledio more likely to get them if the game was closer Selwood would have gotten something

[MalteserMan]

I reckon you are being a bit generous to Ablett...

[kilbluff1985]

I reckon you are being a bit generous to Ablett...

Bookies have him as favourite to

Umpires love giving votes to him

[Mat0369]

Does Waite get the 3? If not he surely gets the 2

I am thinking

3. Waite
2. Heppell
1. Murphy

[kilbluff1985]

yeah my original thought was

Heppel 3
Waite 2
Carlisle 1

felt Carlisle won the game for Essendon

[Toga]

Carlisle starred, agree in thinking he has to poll!

I like the look of your votes, might be tight between Hepp & Waitie tho.

[Mat0369]

I think the 1 vote could have gone to a number of guys. Taggers generally won't get into the votes so I won't include those guys, Murphy was good all game long, Carlisle in the 2nd half, Tex, Gibbs did a good job on Goddard and won a lot of the ball, Melksham winning the game with his late goals will also stand out.

[kilbluff1985]

Carlisle got a bit of the ball early to and pretty much changed the game when he went forward

[Mat0369]

Carlisle got a bit of the ball early to and pretty much changed the game when he went forward

Yeah he did play well early on Waite before he became a headache for whomever played on him. I think you are right that the 1 has to go to an Essendon player. The more I think about it, Melksham could steal the votes with the late goals since it might stick in the umpires minds. I don't think the 1 going to Melksham or Carlisle will matter all too much in the grand scheme of things.

[kilbluff1985]

lol yeah good point

think i'll give it to Carlisle as he really got things going our way

if it makes you feel better i would have given Murphy votes if they won

[Mat0369]

Yeah which is why I took Murph out. In a winning team he gets the votes, probably the 2 behind Waite, but in a loss he probably misses out. Since it was such a close game you never know what they will do. I remember seeing Fev have a best on ground performance in a winning team and Judd got the 3. Knowing the umpires Waite could miss out all together.

[kilbluff1985]

it's possible i mean he didn't do a great deal in the 2nd half did he?