Brownlow Votes

[kilbluff1985]

Sorry if i sounded harsh Ringo replied when had just woken up earlier i do appreciate the help

[Ringo]

No worries no offence taken and I was a little slow on the take up as well. Forgot about the weekly thread.

[stew42]

Ok, so I'm really bored. So I decided to group these Brownlow Votes by team:
Adelaide: 49
BL: 50
Carl: 68
Coll: 76
Ess: 71
Freo: 80
Geel: 80
GCS: 51
GWS: 12
Haw: 81
Melb: 11  ::)
NM: 65
PA: 63
Rich: 73
StK: 31
Syd: 93  8)
WCE: 49
WB: 50

[Ricochet]

lol Ablett 25 of 51 votes

[Mat0369]

3. Simpson
2. Goddard
1. I can't split Ryder/Yarran/Gibbs

[specky92]

No Hurls? 3 goals 2 assists?

Easily Kade and God though

[kilbluff1985]

i like

Goddard 3
Simpson 2
Pears/Hooker

thought Pears was really good Goddard and Simpson hard to split just went Goddard cause Essendon won :P

[kilbluff1985]

Round 22

Collingwood vs West Coast

3 Votes = J. Thomas
2 Votes = S. Pendlebury
1 Votes = D. Swan

Adelaide vs Melbourne

3 Votes = S. Thompson
2 Votes = R. Sloane
1 Votes = P. Dangerfield

North Melbourne vs Hawthorn

3 Votes = S. Mitchell 
2 Votes = J. Ziebell
1 Votes = L. Franklin

Geelong vs Sydney

3 Votes = S. Johnson
2 Votes = J. Selwood
1 Votes = M. Stokes

Carlton vs Essendon

3 Votes = B. Goddard 
2 Votes = K. Simpson
1 Votes = J. Watson

Fremantle vs Port Adelaide

3 Votes = N. Fyfe
2 Votes = Z. Clarke
1 Votes = M. Pavlich

[kilbluff1985]

they are the proposed votes i not done the ladder yet

i only watched the Essendon game today so really stuck on the Freo game and Hawks game

[Spite]

In my opinion, it was;

3 Votes = J. Thomas
2 Votes = D.Swan
1 Votes = S.Pendles

Swan stood out more than pendles. Did a few runs and was just much more noticeable on the night, would be surprised if pendles scored the two above him

[kilbluff1985]

yeah your prob right might change that

[elephants]

Lobbe has to get a vote.

40 hitouts, 15 touches most of which contested, 15 tackles.

He murdered Clarke in the ruck, deserves the 1 imo.

Pav kicked his goals when the game was dead!

[Mat0369]

Even though Carlton lost, it was only by a goal. I still thought Simpson was BOG. The man was everywhere and was winning every important ball that went his way. He and Goddard were the two best by a mile, and because it was such a close game I thought it was difficult to split the 1. There were possibly 5 guys that could have claimed it.

[kilbluff1985]

ok thanks guys

so ele do you think

fyfe 3
Lobbe 2
Clarke 1

??

[elephants]

People seem to think Clarke was close to best on.

I would be happy with

Fyfe
Clarke
Lobbe

Umps would notice Clarke's couple of goals more than Lobbe's tackles I think. Still, giving two ruckmen votes feels wrong :P