Nathan Fyfe???

[Juddster5]

Hey Guys,

I was wondering what your opinion was on having Nathan Fyfe as a uniquish player at the M5 position? Personally, i think he has got massive upside and could easily average 105+. What are your thoughts on this? If you don't think i should get him i can afford anyone except for Beams and GAJ, let me know who i should replace him with. Any ideas or opinions would be greatly appreciated!

[Jukes]

He's not unique, been in like 90% of the boards' teams this pre-season :P but who hasn't aha

I like him for a 100-105 DT average and top 5 in the Brownlow but can't really fit him into the side atm, probably won't force Swanny, Pendles, Stants, Swallow or Danger out of my side anytime soon.

I reckon if you could use the 80k from going him over Stants go for it; if you can't really utilise that, go with the Stantonator imo.

[POK252]

I reckon he's been in an out of my side 100 times so far and still is 50/50 to make my team. This is not good considering I've got less than 2 days to make up my mind. He's my favourite player outside Collingwood and I think he can avg 105 but he's in that awkward price range of not being a premo but nor a MP. Hmmm I'll keep thinking

[Juddster5]

Yeah, thanks alot. I reckon ill upgrade him, just unsure as to who at the moment.

[Andrew]

I reckon he's been in an out of my side 100 times so far and still is 50/50 to make my team. This is not good considering I've got less than 2 days to make up my mind. He's my favourite player outside Collingwood and I think he can avg 105 but he's in that awkward price range of not being a premo but nor a MP. Hmmm I'll keep thinking

Does well against West Coast but another shoulder scare during the pre-season... I'd stay away from Fyfe, replace him with anyone else who tickles your fancy (can't go too wrong really).

[Juddster5]

I reckon he's been in an out of my side 100 times so far and still is 50/50 to make my team. This is not good considering I've got less than 2 days to make up my mind. He's my favourite player outside Collingwood and I think he can avg 105 but he's in that awkward price range of not being a premo but nor a MP. Hmmm I'll keep thinking

He didn't have a bad NAB Cup Campain either did he? He had 1 poor game and he was beast in the other 3! Are you looking at having him in the M5 spot?

[POK252]

I reckon he's been in an out of my side 100 times so far and still is 50/50 to make my team. This is not good considering I've got less than 2 days to make up my mind. He's my favourite player outside Collingwood and I think he can avg 105 but he's in that awkward price range of not being a premo but nor a MP. Hmmm I'll keep thinking

He didn't have a bad NAB Cup Campain either did he? He had 1 poor game and he was beast in the other 3! Are you looking at having him in the M5 spot?

Yeah M5 with Moloney at M6

[me]

fyfe and also mundy are great picks , nice and cheap but surely good for 100+

[Justin Bieber]

Who cares if they are unique. Uniques don't win it for you, the best scorers win it for you. And the best scorers are not unique.

[Ricochet]

Don't worry about the shoulder scare in NAB it was just a stinger
He's good for 105+ this year and should smash the eagles who are without Kerr, NicNat, Wellingham, Embley not 100% and no Rosa

[Adamant]

I've locked him in. He is great value priced at an 89 average. I don't expect him to belt out a 110 average, but he should be a great last stepping stone or possibly an M8 keeper if he pushes above the 105 mark.

I honestly see him getting within 5-7ppg of guys like Redden, Murphy, Jelwood, Danger and he is 80k+ cheaper.

[essendon2]

I've locked him in. He is great value priced at an 89 average. I don't expect him to belt out a 110 average, but he should be a great last stepping stone or possibly an M8 keeper if he pushes above the 105 mark.

I honestly see him getting within 5-7ppg of guys like Redden, Murphy, Jelwood, Danger and he is 80k+ cheaper.

will he cop the scooter tag though?

[Ricochet]

I've locked him in. He is great value priced at an 89 average. I don't expect him to belt out a 110 average, but he should be a great last stepping stone or possibly an M8 keeper if he pushes above the 105 mark.

I honestly see him getting within 5-7ppg of guys like Redden, Murphy, Jelwood, Danger and he is 80k+ cheaper.

will he cop the scooter tag though?

With Kerr, Wellingham, Rosa out and Embley underdone, I don't think eagles can afford to have Scooter tagging

[Tominator]

I've had him all pre-season but I downgraded Broughton to Vlastuin, then upgraded Fyfe and Lonergan to Moloney and Cotchin

He'll do well this year but I'm not gonna lose any sleep on not having him