Which backline is better?

[daniel lucanus]

BACKLINE 1:
Enright, Carrazzo, Fisher, Hodge, Shaw, Hunt, Davis
Bench: Trengove, Webberley
$32, 400 in the bank


BACKLINE 2:
Enright, Carrazzo, Fisher, Hodge, Waters (or Ladson?), Hunt, Kennelly
Bench: Trengove, Davis
$124, 800 in the bank

Please give your opinion on which backline is better
Thanks,

[stevemac]

#2 but switch kennelly for malceski

[Jazz-man]

id be worried about Carrazzo's forward tagging role carrying on into the season proper

[Justin Bieber]

number 2 but ladson ahead of waters. waters too injury prone. maybe change carrazzo to shaw.