Colquhoun v Docherty v Heath

[ben_020285]

I already have Goodes, Terlich, Stevenson and Pittard locked in and don't want any expensive rookies.

Please vote and provide a comment if you would be so kind to convince me as to why I should pick either Colquhoun, Docherty or Heath.

Cheers!

[Luigi197]

Capmbell Heath from Port?
What evidence to you have for me of him?

[tbagrocks]

heath is a decent desposal, but should be a player stopper, Stevenson is the loose ball winner

[dickitch]

What's the current feel on Docherty? I have him as last defender but not convinced he will be named... Then again I can only swap him out for same priced defender and I have all the usual suspects? Much been said on Jack Frost since his elevation? He is cheeeeap!!

[enzedder]

At the moment I have Terlich and Docherty on the pine in defence.
Heath is named in the back pocket. Looks a no-brainer to trade Docherty out for Heath. Unfortunately I know nothing about Heath. Should I do it?

[mabo]

At the moment I have Terlich and Docherty on the pine in defence.
Heath is named in the back pocket. Looks a no-brainer to trade Docherty out for Heath. Unfortunately I know nothing about Heath. Should I do it?

Now 21 years old, Campbell was taken at pick 61 by the Sydney Swans in the 2008 draft and at the age of 17, was the second youngest player taken in the that draft year.

He played 2 games in 2010 against Hawthorn (finished 7th) and Fremantle (finished 6th).

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pg-port-adelaide-power--campbell-heath?year=2010&fantasy=y

Being very young, he was probably fortunate to even get those two games then as he would have only been 19 at the time, and especially considering Sydney is hard side to crack into in the first place.

Personally, I would go with Heath over Docherty & Colquhoun because:

• Barring injury he'll get more games than them
• His body is older than their's.

And most importantly, he's playing and they aren't.  ;D

[enzedder]

At the moment I have Terlich and Docherty on the pine in defence.
Heath is named in the back pocket. Looks a no-brainer to trade Docherty out for Heath. Unfortunately I know nothing about Heath. Should I do it?

Now 21 years old, Campbell was taken at pick 61 by the Sydney Swans in the 2008 draft and at the age of 17, was the second youngest player taken in the that draft year.

He played 2 games in 2010 against Hawthorn (finished 7th) and Fremantle (finished 6th).

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pg-port-adelaide-power--campbell-heath?year=2010&fantasy=y

Being very young, he was probably fortunate to even get those two games then as he would have only been 19 at the time, and especially considering Sydney is hard side to crack into in the first place.

Personally, I would go with Heath over Docherty & Colquhoun because:

• Barring injury he'll get more games than them
• His body is older than their's.

And most importantly, he's playing and they aren't.  ;D

Thanks mabo. Solid logic. :)