Which tiger?

Started by pinochio, March 20, 2013, 08:26:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

?

Lids
16 (43.2%)
Cotch
21 (56.8%)

Total Members Voted: 2

pinochio

thinking cotch will get the grunt of the tags after his 2012....evident this weekend when lower did a job on him....

this is for my M4.....3k of watson :( (could be stanton etc....)
....think these 2 are main candidates at the 580k mark??

let me and FF know :)

Hagebear

I think Cotchin. Yes he'll get plenty of attention but he has the potential to be amazing he he can learnt to break/handle a tag. Lids to be safe.

truBLUE

Tbh i do like the look of Lids  8)

pinochio

tough call ye guys,

these 2 are best options at <580k, right??


still unsure who it will be :)

grimreaper

Either is a safe bet imo..

Wacky Tiger

Quote from: pinochio on March 20, 2013, 08:26:17 PM
thinking cotch will get the grunt of the tags after his 2012....evident this weekend when lower did a job on him....

this is for my M4.....3k of watson :( (could be stanton etc....)
....think these 2 are main candidates at the 580k mark??

let me and FF know :)

Cotchin  got the grunt of the tags in 2012 and will handle them accordingly.

Don't be too concerned with a Mickey Mouse practise match.

Lids copped a couple of tags last year which he struggled with and it would not surprise me if clubs target his run and carry more by trying to shut him down.

Therefore it's a vote for Cotchin for me

Toga

Here's a good article with some stats concerning the two. :)

pinochio

seen it toga, but thx

still dosent give me any definitive answers :(

Toga

No worries pinochio, just thought I'd post it just in case.

Basically I think Deledio for a POD but Cotch is a bit of a safer option re: taggers etc.

pinochio

think cotch will do well with tags? togs

Ricochet

I think that Lids is a safe 110+ where as I'm not sold on Cotchin
Tbh I think Cotch will average slightly less than this year, not by much tho!

Adamant

Both are jets, but I still don't trust Cotch. Lids for safety I reckon.

nrich102

Was meant to go Lids, but pressed cotch (I'm on my phone)

Toga

Quote from: pinochio on March 20, 2013, 10:40:11 PM
think cotch will do well with tags? togs

He was tagged a fair bit last year, and seemed to handle them well. Can remember watching a few games starting with someone sticking close on cotch but by halftime they weren't bothering cos he was just smashing the tags 8)

In my opinion I actually think Lids will be tagged more this season. Cotchin is close to being in the 'untaggables' club, and because of this I think teams will try to negate Cotch's influence on the game by trying to stop Deledio's run and carry... So Cotch can run amuck inside and get as much ball as he wants, but if He can't get it to Deledio on the outside then it's effectively reducing his impact on the game.

That's my take anyway :P

HBTD22

Cotch in my book. Hes going to have an amazing year and drag Richmond to the finals I reckon.