Rate my team please guys (3prem Mids, and a lot of risky mid prices)

Started by mt_williams22, March 20, 2013, 12:56:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

mt_williams22

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Hanley, Vlastuin, Goodes (Docherty, Stevenson)

Mids: Ablett, Watson, Cotchin, Moloney, Embley, Lucas, Wines, O'Meara (Mitchell, Viney)

Rucks: Maric, Kreuzer (Rowe, Currie)

Forwards: Cox, Bartel, Lewis, Kennedy, Varcoe, Karnezis (Macaffer, Lee)

$26,800 left

Hey guys,
Happy with my backline, although cant decide out of Hanley and Heppel?
So,obviously gone with a 3 prem mid lineup, with 3 mid-low price players who I think are undervalued and that at worst I will make a fair bit of cash out of them.
Happy with rucks
Got Lewis over buddy, as I think he is overpriced and will drop due to his hard start to the season. Not against having Kennedy, Karnezis and Varcoe filling up my 3 last spots, as there clearly isn't any rookie talent in the forwards line.

Just wondering what people's thoughts are on this  setup? Yes it's risky, so feel free to critisize or give advise :)

Cheers!

jamez_1983

Interesting approach!

I agree that the mid pricers are a good way to combat the lack of depth in forward rooks.
It doesnt look as healthy in the mids though IMO.
I would lose Embley (injury?) and one of the other two and bring in another prem and a rook like Crouch/MJones.

johnnytheboy1

Backs: not keen on Docherty, Pittard will play more games. Otherwise you have a Solid defence
Mids: Too many mids here. Lucas is a great unique pick though. Only 3 premium mids.
Rucks: Kreuzer a good point of difference
Fwds: Not Sold on Varcoe but i see you already got the 2 options in your team i was going to mention. Good POD in Lewis.

Overall:The Good thing about this team is that it has plenty of Cash cows has the right balance 7.5/10

ubeaut

Nice team, nice uniques. I would change the structure slightly. I'd downgrade Hartlett/Hanley to rookie. Vlastuin and Docherty to Brown and Pittard.

Also Lucas is too much with Moloney and Embley as well. Get a rookie and I'd rather Fyfe/Mundy over Embley as a mid price/fallen prem option. He is getting on and faces competition from Gaff,Wellingham,Masten,Priddis,Kerr,Shuey,Rosa,Selwood (esp the first two who are wingers).

Any cash left I would upgrade 1 of Varcoe,Kennedy or Karnezis.

mt_williams22

Quote from: ubeaut on March 20, 2013, 02:57:50 PM
Nice team, nice uniques. I would change the structure slightly. I'd downgrade Hartlett/Hanley to rookie. Vlastuin and Docherty to Brown and Pittard.

Also Lucas is too much with Moloney and Embley as well. Get a rookie and I'd rather Fyfe/Mundy over Embley as a mid price/fallen prem option. He is getting on and faces competition from Gaff,Wellingham,Masten,Priddis,Kerr,Shuey,Rosa,Selwood (esp the first two who are wingers).

Any cash left I would upgrade 1 of Varcoe,Kennedy or Karnezis.

I'm intrigued to see if Embley gets names tomorrow night. With Rosa, Wellingham and Kerr all out for a few weeks he should feature a bit in the first month at least.

Also, will brown and pittard definitely play?