Fyfe v hartlett. End of season average??? Simple poll.

[Bigjim]

Who do u think will score more by the end of season assuming they both play equal amount of games....

My thoughts are fyfe has a higher ceiling. Both are of similar risk to injuries.

Tossing up between these two as my 13th keeper going into the season??.?.??

[harrynutts]

Fyfe will average more. Hartlett is a defender, comparing apples and oranges. Overall Hartlett the slightly better value IMO. Both decent picks provided they can avoid injury for once.

[fever]

fyfe

[Bigjim]

Hardly apples and oranges when the question is who will score higher. Have hartlett starting in the back line and Brett goodes starting in the midfield. It becomes a like for like if I swing goodes to starting in the back line and hartlett then become fyfe starting in the midfield. Same amount of starting rookies, same amount of starting keepers (my assumption is fyfe will score enough to become M8)

[Spinking]

I think Fyfe will average higher, however a consideration would be that it is quite possible that Hartlett might be in the top 6 defenders this year if he stays injury free, however Fyfe is unlikely to be a top 8 mid even if he stays on the park.

[Marstar]

The poll is simple. Fyfe.

However what you need to consider is picking:

Hartlett = upgrading Goodes to a 120ppg midfielder by round 8.
Fyfe = upgrading Goodes to Hartlett by round 8.

From Round 8 -> 23 Hartlett and a 120ppg mid is better than Fyfe + Hartlett.

Of coarse if you think Hartlett won't be in the top 6 defenders this year then refer to the 1st line. Fyfe. Simple.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 ???
Fyfe  IMO has a much higher ceiling than Hartlett.  Having said that, and meant it, I have Hartlett but not Fyfe. Reason being have gone 4 prem 6 rookies in the mid and believe Hartlett may finish top 6 in defence.  Best of luck whicheverway.  ;)

[Hagebear]

I think Fyfe should average 15-20 more then Harts this year. I think Hartlett's role will change throughout the year affecting his scoring.

[tbagrocks]

Fyfe to gun 112+

Hartlett to gun also 8)  105+