sammy123's RD1 team SC 2012 RANK 990(advice really needed)

sammy123 · March 19, 2013, 07:40:46 PM

Goddard,gibbs,duffield,goodes,stevenson,terlich(docherty,colquhoun)

ablett,pendles,jpk,Jelwood,deledio,wines,k.mitchell,o'meara(crouch,viney)

jacobs,kruz(currie,rowe)

franklin,cox,rocky,kennedy,karnezis,macaffer(kerridge,neade)

like swallow as a POD. but like murphy as well. But thought i could downgrade Murphy to a rich/mundy/fyfe or hannebury.

then use cash to upgrade kruzuer to jacobs/mcevoy maybe roughy?

i believe kerridge will play more than lee IMO

thoughts?

to tbag dangerfield might makw team if i decidw to drop maric to jacobs and upgrade murph to him

hawkers65 · March 19, 2013, 08:24:12 PM

Very solid team Sammy!! If i was you i would do your suggested trade and go Maric to Jacobs and Murphy to Dangerfield as i really don't like Murph as a premo as he can be tagged out of it quite easily. I would also go Swallow done to Mundy or Rich because IMO he will never reach i true premo status.This will then free up some cash to go Kruz to a premo ruck.

8.75/10

Thats just my thoughts, take them or leave it.

sammy123 · March 19, 2013, 09:24:56 PM

they sound very good. Thanka hawkers

caluuum · March 19, 2013, 09:36:31 PM

Yeah I've got the same view as hawkers. Very good overall team but I'm not a fan of Murphy as he seems to struggle with tags.
And I'm not to sure on kreuzer either but he could be unleashed under malthouse
8.5/10

bkimm32 · March 19, 2013, 10:30:48 PM

Nice team mate.. Like the Swallow inclusion. Can never seem to pick him from the stop myself for some reason, but reliable pick.

each line looks pretty solid really.

BLBBLB · March 19, 2013, 10:44:34 PM

Solid team Sammy.

Backline: Good mix of premiums and rookies. Obviously need to see who gets the nod, but you've got the right ones. Very similiar to mine.

Mids: Very strong...agree with the other comments below re: Murphy. However I am a fan of Swallow, had him last year and pulled out some really solid scores. Great POD also...I don't think I played one team who had him last year. I think you should stick with him.

Rucks: Kreuz could be a masterstroke, or a failure. I'll leave it up to your gut feeling on him. Personally I think he's too great a risk, but obviously your call.

Fwds: Can't knock any of those inclusions. Kennedy should explode this year.

Overall I think your team looks pretty strong. Well done

BLBBLB · March 19, 2013, 11:09:40 PM

Please review mine..thanks

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74723.0.html

nightwalker_1310au · March 20, 2013, 12:47:12 AM

Hey mate nice solid team. Can't fault. Rate 9/10
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74278.0.html

ando_10 · March 20, 2013, 11:24:51 AM

Quote from: sammy123 on March 19, 2013, 07:40:46 PM
Goddard,gibbs,duffield,goodes,stevenson,terlich(docherty,colquhoun)

ablett,pendles,jpk,Murphy,a.swallow,wines,k.mitchell,o'meara(crouch,viney)

maric,kruz(currie,rowe)

franklin,cox,rocky,kennedy,karnezis,macaffer(kerridge,neade)

backs: almost identical to mine i like it

mids: maybe one more premo then id like in there but each to their own i guess still solid

rucks: no problems here kruezer is overdue for a good year.

forwards: hopefully kennedy stays fit and you'll be flying

9/10 for mine

hoon1 · March 20, 2013, 11:54:20 AM

Love your team but dont trust kreuzer at all. every year ive had him ive been burnt. 9/10
Please rate my team
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74939.0.html

sammy123 · March 20, 2013, 12:04:10 PM

3 changes

maric to JACOBS

Murphy to DELEDIO

swallow to JELWOOD

GOOD BAD

Typhnn · March 20, 2013, 12:07:54 PM

Team looks pretty solid mate...

Def Bench - i'm 50/50 if both will play early on in the season, check Round 1 selections... to be sure...

Mid - Murphy NAB cup stats are down, due to the load Gibbs has picked up & swallow hasn't hit prem status just yet, but this could be a good season for him... i would swap out Murph & Swallow and prob bring in Watson/Danger & Fyfe possibly...

Ruck - Solid

Fwd - Solid (Kerridge check for Round 1 teams 50/50 if playing..)

9/10

boneman · March 20, 2013, 02:27:31 PM

Def: Looks fairly solid...similar picks to me except for Colquhoun. I've gone Docherty but he is not a lock. There seems to be plenty of rookie options in this area that are firing!

Mid: Very solid and some POD action with Lids and Selwood. Not sure how many might take Jelwood due to his concussions and hard attack on the footy.

Ruck: Sauce is a nice option, Kreuz is an interesting one. Alot of people will want him to perform after a let down last year. Where will Mick play him. If it was lone ruck I would lock him in. Maric a better option in the end but could he have a down year after smashing it last year?

For: Looks nice, maybe Karnezis (alot of hype over this bloke) at is price range he's an interesting pick for all. I would have him over Varcoe in saying this. Kerridge JS is the only concern here.

Nice looking squad and should be pretty solid

sammy123 · March 20, 2013, 07:09:14 PM

anyone else?

Jmachete · March 20, 2013, 07:33:29 PM

Goddard,gibbs,duffield,goodes,stevenson,terlich(docherty,colquhoun)

ablett,pendles,jpk,Jelwood,deledio,wines,k.mitchell,o'meara(crouch,viney)

jacobs,kruz(currie,rowe)

franklin,cox,rocky,kennedy,karnezis,macaffer(kerridge,neade)

Watch out for docherty and get another rookie word is he will be vested

I dont really trust Lids to score that well for his price, I would be looking at fyfe or mundy and free up some cash

Kruz could be very good this year and make a great POD

Keep an eye on the rookies including Macaffer to make sure they get games, I agree Kerrige looks better then Lee at this stage

8.5/10