Ablett or a gun ruck

[danksey]

so i have lost all interest in berger even if he plays he will be underdone.

So had rucks as Cox / Z.Smith
and mids prems as Ablett / Pendles / JPK / Danger

If i drop Ablett to cotchin i can then udgrade Smith to either Kruezer / Goldstein

Do i leave it as Smith and hope he can average 80+ until i can upgrade him or downgrade ablett and risk get burned by not picking him.

Any suggestions?

[kilbluff1985]

keep Ablett

[ronl]

Drop anyone but Ablett.

[MC]

I predict Cotchin will average 125 and Ablett will go for 135. I would say the points difference will be marginal by making this trade, though if you had said that the ruck upgrade had been to Cox/Maric I would have said go for it!

Verdict: Keep Ablett.

[GCSkiwi]

Ablett will be your captain I presume so remember you lose double the difference between him and the next player. No way would you drop him to Cotchin. You could potentially drop him to Swan (which even then I wouldn't) but that doesn't make you much money...

Smith > Kreuz/Goldy wont make up the lost score of Ablett > Cotchin x2

[Deadly6]

You only lose the difference not double :)

[Ricochet]

You only lose the difference not double :)

GCSkiwi is right, its double the difference

Ablett scores 150 as Captain = 300
Cotchin scores 120 as Captain = 240

30 point initial difference = 60 point Captain difference

[Deadly6]

You only lose the difference not double :)

GCSkiwi is right, its double the difference

Ablett scores 150 as Captain = 300
Cotchin scores 120 as Captain = 240

30 point initial difference = 60 point Captain difference


150x2 120 = 420. 120x2 + 150 = 390 = 30 points difference

[Ricochet]

You only lose the difference not double :)

GCSkiwi is right, its double the difference

Ablett scores 150 as Captain = 300
Cotchin scores 120 as Captain = 240

30 point initial difference = 60 point Captain difference


150x2 120 = 420. 120x2 + 150 = 390 = 30 points difference

If your downgrading Ablett you won't get his 150 score...