Duffield or Hartlett

[Slammer]

Can not make up my mind with this one. Hartlett playing through mids and loves to tackle. Duffy is proven without Broughton.
Have Goddard, Gibbs and probably going with the 3 gun defenders only strategy. Would love both but cannot seem to fit them in.
Hartlett yes is injury prone but is due to have a run of luck.

[tbagrocks]

Hartlett's a super star mate!

[Ricochet]

Personally I would pick Duffield. The latter part of 2012 showed us what to expect from Freo in terms of game plan. He uses the ball well and will the the go-to out of defence.

[fever]

this is one of those decisions that's so close i dont think it matters who you go with. much more important decisions surround structure and trade planning.

that said, i would go duff, just. reason being hartlett's inability to play a full season.

[tor01doc]

I've gone Hanley!

Out of those 2 - 50/50 so if you can't decide on points, defer to DPP eligibility and bye structure.

So HH has DPP.

Which bye - same.

So HH.