After 4 months i'm done!

Started by cortez, March 18, 2013, 12:58:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

cortez

After 4 months months of countless hours on this site and supercoach i believe i am finally done and ready for the season to start this Friday. This is what i believe to be my finished team. please leave any thoughts on what you think of it and how high i could go.
Cheers for everyones help. It has been much appreciated.
Cortez

Brendon Goddard, Bryce Gibbs, Paul Duffield, Jack Grimes, Brett Goodes, Jasper Pittard
Lewis Stevenson, Dean Terlich

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Pendlebury, Josh P. Kennedy, David Mundy, Brent Moloney, Kane Mitchell, Oliver Wines, Brad Crouch
Jaeger O'Meara, Jack Viney

Dean Cox, Sam Jacobs
Mark Blicavs, Daniel Currie

Lance Franklin, Dayne Zorko, Tom Rockliff, Josh J. Kennedy, Patrick Karnezis, Brent Macaffer
Tom Lee, Sam Rowe

$3,000 left

tor01doc

Nice cortez.

Grimes will be top 10 if he stays fit. Just remeber at some stage you'll be considering Shaw (yes you will), Waters, Hanley, Hartlett and maybe Birchall and Heppell. Is Grimes likely to be as good as most of these guys? If so, you'll slip backwards.

Mundy @ M3 is a bit weaker than otherr teams we're seeing.

I think Moloney is too high to start as he's not likely to be a keeper IMO. If you want him for M9 then maybe, but still too much.

Let's hope Leue does in fact start. You'll save some money in your rucks then. You could start Jacobs and Leue, put Rowe R4.

Will Tom Lee get games?

Good luck.

cortez

Quote from: tor01doc on March 18, 2013, 01:29:16 PM
Nice cortez.

Grimes will be top 10 if he stays fit. Just remeber at some stage you'll be considering Shaw (yes you will), Waters, Hanley, Hartlett and maybe Birchall and Heppell. Is Grimes likely to be as good as most of these guys? If so, you'll slip backwards.

Mundy @ M3 is a bit weaker than otherr teams we're seeing.

I think Moloney is too high to start as he's not likely to be a keeper IMO. If you want him for M9 then maybe, but still too much.

Let's hope Leue does in fact start. You'll save some money in your rucks then. You could start Jacobs and Leue, put Rowe R4.

Will Tom Lee get games?

Good luck.

Cheers tor01doc

With Grimes, his last 7 games last year he averaged 107 and if he can keep that up for this season will definately be top 6 defenders.

Mundy is at M4 not M3 and is va bit of a risk but to take it knowing that he is capable of an avg of 115+

Moloney, well at $360K for someone who will avg between 90-105 is a pretty good deal in my eyes. WIll only be there till i upgrade but would rather have someone like that than someone i cant depend on.

Leuey isn't on my radar atm, I dont like the injuries and cant be bothered with the crap of him going in and out throughout the year. Im happy with the rucks atm with COx moving up forward when i upgrade a ruckman

And i think Tom Lee will get games, is starting to get used to the pace of AFL and is lookig better with every game. Also Stkilda didnt get him in and give up a first round pick for him not to play.

tor01doc

Then 9.4/10!   ;D

Stand by your decisions.

j

This team is great, one of the best I've seen. The only suggestion I'd make is Byrnes over karnezis but that won't make a huge difference. 9/10

Ringo

Nice Team now Cortez

Just the slight doubt on Mundy at M4 but stick to your gut feel there,  As you say if he averages 115 which he is capable of then no worries.  Just a risk at M4 imo would rather the risk at M5 for balance but just personal.

Rate 9.4/10 as well Well done.

cortez

Quote from: Ringo on March 18, 2013, 04:19:14 PM
Nice Team now Cortez

Just the slight doubt on Mundy at M4 but stick to your gut feel there,  As you say if he averages 115 which he is capable of then no worries.  Just a risk at M4 imo would rather the risk at M5 for balance but just personal.

Rate 9.4/10 as well Well done.

Cheers Ringo and yea Mundy is a risk but if you're not gonna take risks you're not going to get anywhere and with Mundy i do like him a lot this year especially with Freo looking like a top 4 side this year.

cortez

Quote from: j on March 18, 2013, 04:11:43 PM
This team is great, one of the best I've seen. The only suggestion I'd make is Byrnes over karnezis but that won't make a huge difference. 9/10

Thanks J, i think i will keep Karnezis in though. Has looked really good tis pre season.

The_duke

I had the same concerns in terms of keeping Byrnes vs Karnezis, i like your team though!

tbagrocks

Well ballanced side and solid no worry ruck setup, done well mate!

nightwalker_1310au

Nice solid team mate. Love the risks in mundy as your mid 3. No risks no rewards. So many good options you've chosen and all viable and great choices. Ruck line up excellent and forwards have chosen the right amount with the added spice of including buddy. Defense are solid and like the grimes pick.
Team rating 9.87/10
Can you please rate my team
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74278.0.html

fever

very balanced team. i disagree on a few personnel issues, but it's all to do with personal preference.

i'm not enamoured with jj kennedy or moloney though fwiw. i think you'd be improved turning moloney into a rookie and jj into a premo.

pieman18

pretty good side...but i think on thursday night you will be running around trying to find a cheap fwd rookie...mcaffer is sub fodder for sure...i have him on bench and dont have to worry if he plays full game...too many players who will go 50-60.....i think 300,000 coaches are pitting there hopes on mcaffer and karnezis...good luck with that....my fwd 6 is kennedy from west coast...the rookies on the fwd line are crap....treated the fwd line more like the midfield as there are plenty of 80-100's up there...cheers

jackel82

Really solid mate a couple of risks but with sound logic. I hope it comes off for ya
forward like almost identicle to mine except a rookie.
cheers

cortez

#14
A couple of slight changes to the backs and forwards, what do people think, improvement?

Brendon Goddard, Bryce Gibbs, Dyson Heppell, Nick Vlastuin, Brett Goodes, Jasper Pittard Lewis Stevenson, Dean Terlich

Gary Ablett jnr,Scott Pendlebury,JoshP. Kennedy, David Mundy, Brent Moloney, Oliver Wines, Kane Mitchell, Brad Crouch Jaeger O'Meara, Jack Viney

Dean Cox, Sam Jacobs Mark Blicavs,Daniel Currie

Lance Franklin, Patrick Ryder, Tom Rockliff, Travis Cloke, Josh J. Kennedy, Patrick Karnezis Brent Macaffer, Sam Rowe
$12,900 left