Been up for an hour still no comments

NMFC97 · March 17, 2013, 01:55:48 PM

Goddard Gibbs Duff Vlaustin Goodes Terlich
Pittard Stevenson

Ablett Pendles Danger Murph Mundy Stevens O'mera Mitchell
Crouch Viney

Cox Bellchambers
Currie Mcbean

Franklin Bartel Rockcliff Martin Karnezis Macaffer
Lee Neade

Advice on all lines would be much appreciated.

j · March 17, 2013, 03:13:18 PM

If you change Bartel to Jetta you will Have an extra $100k to upgrade Stevens or vlastuin

Big Mac · March 17, 2013, 04:48:35 PM

Team is actually really good, can't fault the structure. I would only change a couple of players, but they're just based on opinion.
Bartel = Zorko (Bartel is too old and he's average has been declining every year since his peak).
Bellchambers = Ryder (Hird has hinted that this year could be the year that Ryder steps up, and I believe he has a higher ceiling than Bellchambers).

The only obvious flaw is starting a forward rookie, but you're not alone on that one.

jackel82 · March 17, 2013, 05:02:48 PM

Many are of the thought that Vlaustin will get the vest often mate. Other then that very good team

nightwalker_1310au · March 17, 2013, 05:35:40 PM

Nice solid team mate. Can't fault at all. Can you rate my team please
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74278.0.html

DC13 · March 17, 2013, 07:04:42 PM

DEF: Good choice in Duffield, should smash it this year, hopefully Vlastuin gets best 22 and doesn't cop the vest and the other rookies look good! 9.5/10

MID: Really good, like the choice of the 3 super prems and murphy who is underpriced and should go back to 115+. Stevens could be good if he plays, if not then get wines maybe and the rest of the rookies are good. 10/10

RUCK: Good choice with cox as he is a must have and love the bellchambers pick, should be good this year and really improve in the number 1 ruck role at Essendon. Not sure on McBean, may just be for DPP link? 10/10

FWD: Really really good. Very strong and like the bartel choice along with martin who I believe should finally pull out a massive year...hopefully. great pick with karnezis!!! 10/10

Overall: Probably the best time I have seen yet mate, really good structure and looks great, very strong and I reckon your in for a good season, good luck mate. Almost perfect, 39.5/40

Please Rate Mine: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74383.0.html

NMFC97 · March 17, 2013, 07:28:55 PM

Cheers for the positive feedback guys. Should i downgrade Nick Vlaustin to Sam Docherty and then upgrade Bellchambers to either Goldstein Kreuzer or Mumford?

the captain · March 17, 2013, 08:03:05 PM

Def: Good, nothing really needs changing, just watch rookies come round 1 teams.
Mids: Good structure, only change I would make it Stevens to Wines, but depends what you think of Stevens.
Ruc: Good, not a fan of Bellchambers personally, but if you think he'll have a good year go ahead. If money allows upgrade McBean to Rowe, likely to be in the team when Waite isn't.
Fwd: Bartel could be getting a bit old, but not a bad pick, good be good. Interesting with Karnezis, should score much higher than he has, but still a bit of a risk there.

Overall you're pretty much there though.

Quote from: NMFC97 on March 17, 2013, 07:28:55 PM
Cheers for the positive feedback guys. Should i downgrade Nick Vlaustin to Sam Docherty and then upgrade Bellchambers to either Goldstein Kreuzer or Mumford?

Vlaustin could be a very good rookie, likely to play, but may get the vest a couple of times. Docherty is a risk, would need to wait to see if he actually plays, but I would personally upgrade Bellchambers, not to Goldstein though, bit to much of a risk with the form Currie has been in.