Which one do you perfer please rate

[jackel82]

new team

old team


Please tell be which one you prefer and why. open to all suggestions. Send me a link if you would like yours rated too.

thanks

[cheesy]

new one by a mile. chose some better options here and there, like moving cox into the ruck
fitting franklin in. kennedy over jack
i'm liking zorko more than walker though

here's me
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74198.0.html

[j]

New team looks good but I don't think Mcevoy will perform as well as people think, you could try downgrading your ruck to something like Jacobs / Z Smith (just a suggestion) then you'll have some cash to upgrade karnezis

[jackel82]

thanks cheesy, but thats the old one you are refering too. I posted the old then new. sorry it might be a bit confusing. But old team with zorko over walker. If I go that team I will do that.

thanks J, I can change mc evoy straight to Jacobs about the same price. who do I upgrade Karnezis too? I will have 362000 for another forward?

cheers anyone else?

[BB67th]

The new team looks better, I actually like the pick of McEvoy and I think he will do very well as the Saints only real ruckman this year. He is also at the stage where he is just about to explode.  Bellchambers will probably do just as well if not better than McEvoy though looking at the teams and I would stick with the rucks you have in team 2.

Cox in the ruck looks good, don't worry about Moloney at M5, he will score plenty of points this year. I would also rather have Zorko in there over Walker and Karnezis will score a lot more than Varcoe. I wouldn't go for 3 lions in one line though so maybe just get Karnezis in?

Looks like you've got a few solid options to go for there, so it will be a hard choice splitting them.

Check out my team?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71225.0.html

[jackel82]

Thanks BB67th gave you a rate too mate.

With all consitorations in mind I am leaning towards the cox team but I will swap walker for zorko and varcoe to Karnezis, 3 brisbane player is a bit of a concern but Karnezis will be upgraded later down the road.

So its looking like a combination of the 2.


I am now even toying with the idea of changing the backline to fit mundy in for molony. But it involves 3 dons in the backline. Although I could change hibbard to atly, but I like hibbard a lot more.

[johnnytheboy1]

I would say team 1 although there isn't much in it as team 1 has the better midfield & Defence as Docherty shouldn't be in the team. Like the Pick of Kieran Jack.Cotchin struggled when he was tagged by Lower yesterday.