Here we go footy fanatics < perfect set up> Royalz-With-Cheese. <rate for rate>

[nightwalker_1310au]

# Here we go fellas final line up prior to round 1. Rate for rate. All criticism is welcome. Good or bad.

Royalz-With-Cheese-

Back line: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, P.Duffield,  T.Armstrong, L.Stevenson, B.Goodes.
Reserves:
(D.Terlich, S.Docherty)

Mid: G.Ablett, D.Beams, T.Cotchin, A.Swallow, B.Moloney, K.Lucas, B.Crouch, K.Mitchell.
Reserves:
(J.Viney,  J.O'meara)

Rucks: W.Minson, T.Bellchambers
Reserves:
(D.Currie, C.Sinclair)

Forwards: T.Rockliff, D.Cox, M.Robinson, M.De Bour, K.Harper, P.Karnezis.
Reserves:                     
(J.Neade, M.Maccaffer)

[nightwalker_1310au]

# Here we go fellas final line up prior to round 1. Rate for rate. All criticism is welcome. Good or bad.

[pooj11]

Def: looking pretty good, only doubt armstrong, 8.5/10
Mid: Pretty good, nice mix of rookies, premiums and mid-priced, 9/10
Ruck: Better options than Minson IMO (eg, Jacobs, Ryder), 8/10
For: Decent i would say, only i think varcoe will have a better year than harper, 9/10

Overall: A very nice team indeed, 34.5/40

Good luck :)

[nightwalker_1310au]

Thanks mate.

[cotchin9]

Pretty Solid team only changes i would make would be
Duffield- Hartlett or Heppell
Stevenson - Pittard
Lucas- Wines
Swallow - Dangerfield
Minson - McEnvoy or Jacobs
Harper - Neade
De Bour- Zorko

[nightwalker_1310au]

Thanks mate.

[RookieDTer]

Back line: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, P.Duffield,  T.Armstrong, L.Stevenson, B.Goodes.
Reserves: (D.Terlich, S.Docherty)

Mid: G.Ablett, D.Beams, T.Cotchin, A.Swallow, B.Moloney, K.Lucas, B.Crouch, K.Mitchell.
Reserves: (J.Viney,  J.O'meara)

Rucks: W.Minson, T.Bellchambers
Reserves: (D.Currie, C.Sinclair)

Forwards: T.Rockliff, D.Cox, M.Robinson, M.De Bour, K.Harper, P.Karnezis.
Reserves: (J.Neade, M.Maccaffer)

I prefer Heppel over Duffield.
Not 100% convinced Armstrong has done enough.... did have a shower match versus Port... There are probably enough good Defense rookies that I'd swap him out for one of them.... but, I completely understand if you want to keep him.

You didn't say how much cash you have left.... can you go -Pittard +Stevenson?

I rate Lids over Cotchin... Lids has had a much better pre-season, to be honest. Also looks like Cotchin will get tagged more, for what it is worth.

Personally, I'd start O'Meara on the field over Mitchell, but minor point.

Minson!? Interesting choice, any particular reason?

Why Sinclair instead of Daw/Gorringe/Witts?

Fair enough at forward line.... but I don't think Neade will play enough, I'd prefer Tommy Lee.

Rate for rate :)? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,73733.msg1016830.html#msg1016830

Cheers