Josh Caddy M5?

[EL TIGER]

Anyone considering Caddy at the troblesome M5?  :-\

Played 22 last year, has looked good at the Cats so far and Scott said he thought he'd bring something new and exciting to their midfield in 2013...

[Colliwobblers]

NO

expected a breakout season from the spud last season. didn't get it. won't get it this season.

think he will be a solid player like most hard at it in and under older cats mids he will be a fine replacement for them, but a high possession winning fantasy slut i fear he will never be.

could be proved wrong but he failed me last season so i am not going back until he averages 120.

[EL TIGER]

Damn.. Varcoe the better choice?

[Colliwobblers]

varcoe isnt as good a pick as karnezis but that type of player belongs in your fwd line not your midfield.

the only players i would have at M5 would be these;

1. ELITE MID
2. MOLONEY
3. K LUCAS
4. (MID PRICED POTENTIAL ELITE MID) - Fyfe / Gaff / Mundy?  ect ect
5. Rook

in that order.

[nightwalker_1310au]

Totally agree with you mate. Deffinately in that order.

[quinny88]

varcoe isnt as good a pick as karnezis but that type of player belongs in your fwd line not your midfield.

the only players i would have at M5 would be these;

1. ELITE MID
2. MOLONEY
3. K LUCAS
4. (MID PRICED POTENTIAL ELITE MID) - Fyfe / Gaff / Mundy?  ect ect
5. Rook

in that order.

Spot on

[Marstar]

Spot on

Don't you have Mundy at M5? :P