"Royalzs-With-Cheese" Super Coach Team Thread and Diary <Rate for Rate>

[sammy123]

love the team cannot fault except you gave watts. You have balls. He's in my stay away list dont ever touch. Hes to unpredictable scores well some days then others hes shower

also JPK will score better than JACK IMO a swans supporter

[nightwalker_1310au]

Thanks mate. How's your final team going ATM. I've changed my line up so many times just like you. So mny radical ideas we both have mate. Hope we both do good this year. I'm aiming for top 500 his year.

[Babylove]

Team update:

<Final team > pending injuries before round 1 commencement. What's everyone's thoughts on this line up. Please rate for rate. All criticism good or bad is welcome. Thank you

Royalz-With-Cheese
   
Back line: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, P.Duffield,  T.Armstrong, L.Stevenson, B.Goodes.
Reserves:
(D.Terlich, S.Docherty)

Mid: G.Ablett, D.Beams,J.P.Kennedy, T.Cotchin, B.Moloney, K.Lucas, B.Crouch, K.Mitchell.
Reserves:
(J.Viney,  J.O'meara)

Rucks: W.Minson, T.Bellchambers
Reserves:
(D.Currie, S.Rowe)

Forwards: T.Rockliff, D.Cox, M.Robinson, J.Watts, K.Harper, P.Karnezis.
Reserves:                     
(J.Neade, M.Maccaffer)

I still think that Minson & Harper are iffy choices, but I like the rest of your team.  I also think that JPK is a better option than Jack if you can afford him.  Good Luck  :)

[greco272]

No Franklin or Cox..? You'r already behind the 8-ball.

Minson is a road to no-where, won't ever become a premiem.

Players like K.Harper, M.Robinson, J.Watts are all risks i would look at picking maybe 1 or 2 of those guys very uncertain they will all break out into premiem players this year.

Too many risks with not alot of upside? Try at least get Cox then we are moving in the right direction.

[tor01doc]

The good : only fielding 4 rookies - minimises sub risk and JS issues

The bad : only about 10 genuine keepers

The ugly : Minson and Harper

Like it overall though

[nightwalker_1310au]

Thanks mate.

[nightwalker_1310au]

No Franklin or Cox..? You'r already behind the 8-ball.

Minson is a road to no-where, won't ever become a premiem.

Players like K.Harper, M.Robinson, J.Watts are all risks i would look at picking maybe 1 or 2 of those guys very uncertain they will all break out into premiem players this year.

Too many risks with not alot of upside? Try at least get Cox then we are moving in the right direction.

Regarding this statement mate I appreciate your comment and take everything people say but before you start making judgements look at my team. Don't say no cox when you can clearly see the f1 is cox. Yes I may not have Franklin but overall I have probably a very strong team and think I chose the right players. Only player I'm concern with in my team is jack watts but over then that there all good picks. Harper will get more run in the middle and if you look at all the nab games Harvey been playing but remember Harvey out for 7 weeks and harper expected to step up in that role mate. Thanks for comments.

[FisherSaints]

I think you Gould go Harper to a mid pricer if you have the cash. Your rucks are dangerous in scoring but they have JS so will play. Like the DPP link with Cox and ROwe

8.5/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74319.msg1023584.html#msg1023584

[DC13]

DEF: Looks good mate, love the choice of Duffield, would have him myself if I could afford him and same goes with Tony Armstrong, had him a few times but just cant fit him in atm, if he gets games he should score well after his NAB form as long as he avoids the vest. Good basic rookie choices. 9.5/10

MID: Little different again but looks good. Beams is a good choice as everyone seems to go with swan and pendles and beams has the potential to pull out massive scores of 150+ which could give you an edge. Ablett, JPK and cotchin are all guns and should all score well averaging over 120+. Moloney should rack up solid scores and average 90's I think. Contested possessions and a clearance king which can get some solid SC scores. Also had Lucas but once again cannot afford him now haha, if he plays and avoids the vest I can see him averaging around 80, good pick. 10/10

RUCK: Minson is a little different but can score well and goes very unnoticed by many. Bit risky as there are much better prems out there in my opinion but could be okay. Like the bellchambers pick, should do really well as number 1 ruck at the bombers and average in the 90's, could be a straight swap for naitanui once he regains form. 8.5/10

FWD: Really like it! No buddy is a risk but his hard draw is a bit off putting. Rocky and Cox will smash it as usual and robbo should average close to 100 under mick, had some huge games in NAB. Like the Watts pick, think he will do well this year off half back, just a little worried about him attracting the tag if he continues playing well there. Harper is an interesting choice and love the pick of karnezis, pretty much a must have in my opinion, in for a massive year off the wing hopefully. 10/10

Overall: Really good and a good range of uniques and a few risks, good to see a different team, good luck mate, very good side. 38/40

Please Rate Mine: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74383.0.html

[nightwalker_1310au]

Thank you DC13 I just didn't want to end up like everyone else. Having a carbon copy team. The only way to win this comp is by beig unique and throwing a spanner to the lineup. Will rate your team now.

[Regs81]

Back looks good. Not sure docherty will play much, but there is heaps of other options
Mids,: like the POD with luca
Rucks: not a big fan of either. There is much better options, but they could be the difference
Forwards: I would get another premium. Downgrade either watts or Robinson to make some money
Overall good team mate

[NMFC97]

Pretty solid team mate!

Just a couple of queries:
Harper: As a North Supporter doesn't get enough of the ball to be worth considering in Supercoach. Maybe consider next couple of years when he works on winning more hard ball.

I would only pick one of Brent Moloney and Kane Lucas both quite risky so pick 1 of them and downgrade the other to a rookie.

Actually like the pick of Will Minson, Bulldogs sole ruckman so will continue to average well. Not sure he'll go up significantly though.

Like the pick of Dayne Beams good pod which many people will stay away from with the likes of Swanny and Pendles to pick from.

[nightwalker_1310au]

Thanks mate. The reason I picked Harper over most other players is simply as a extra cash fast supply cause Harvey out for 7 rounds and Harper stepping up and going to fill Harvey role. I figure if he averages 70+ per game ill be happy for 6 rounds then offload for extra cash and pick up a prem in that department. Picked the unique picks of Moloney and Lucas simply cause there proven themselves and will score well. Overall think I picked right structure fellas. Thanks everyone for input.

Feel free to send your teams to me so I can rate it for you fan footy fanatics.

[tbagrocks]

Don't mind the smokies at all, only Harper i'd rid of, but having more than one midfield midpricer is too a big of a risk

Otherwise the team is decent

[Jroo]

Nice work mate.
Backline is strong. 3 guns (I like Duffman, great unique) and I reckon Armstrong will get games now that Alex Johnson is injured. Great rookie choices.
I like your midfield, 4 guns (2 uniques which I like) and Molnoey and Lucas are good picks. Both are cheap! Rookies are good.
:o very unique ruckline. Winson is very uqniue and Bellchambers should be a premuim by year's end.
Very strong forward line! 4 guns (which 2 are unique) and I like it  8) not 100% sold on Harper, but think he could break out and same with Karmezis, but I think he's a better chance than Harper.
Very unique team, I like it. 8.5/10