Which 2 Defenders - Round 2 with functioning Poll :P

Started by Marstar, March 16, 2013, 12:07:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Pick 2

Duffield
Hanley
Hartlett

Marstar

Duffield, Hanley and Hartlette.  How many ppg do you think separate them?

Hagebear

Duffield and Hanley for me. Duff has looked awesome this year and is getting plenty of the ball while Hanley looks to be playing slot higher up the ground and will reap the rewards imo. Harts is still a good pick just not sure on his role at this stage. Could play off half back a fair but and thus will bring a certain tag.

DoctorRush

Duff & Hanley for me too.
Mainly cos Hamish's role is partially unknown, but will also play in a losing side most weeks. And he's no Ablett

Colliwobblers

me 3 hartlett tempts me in DT but not in SC not over these two anyway

Marstar

In a similar thread today (http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74294.0.html) the votes went like this:

Duffield    - 9
Hartlett    - 12
Hanley    - 3

Strange? :P

Colliwobblers

pretty similar if you ask me, pick one of the first two :)

Marstar

How is that similar?  :o

Hartlett goes form the 'worst' when you can pick 2 (including him and another), to the undeniable 'favourite' if you only have to pick one.

Marstar

To put into context that's like asking which 2 from:

Danger, Cotchin and Murphy. Murphy getting the least votes.

Then asking which one for M3 and Murphy getting the most votes :P

Colliwobblers

Quote from: Marstar on March 16, 2013, 11:01:44 PM
How is that similar?  :o

Hartlett goes form the 'worst' when you can pick 2 (including him and another), to the undeniable 'favourite' if you only have to pick one.

SORRY - My mistake , i thought it was hartlett with 3 in your post from the other thread poll - just noticed it was hanley.

It is easy for people to say hartlett is the best in a poll, as he should be an elite mid one day if he stays fit.

but ask them if they are going to start the 2013 fantasy season with him.

The SC figures:

Duffied owned by 5.9% of teams
Hanley owned by 3% of teams
Hartlett owned by 0% of teams

not sure if that means not one team in SC has him or if it means less than .1%, I would say the latter but you get the picture.

Marstar