Newman & Lucas or Heppel & Wines?

[Benus]

Hey guys,

Am tossing up between these two for my D4 & M6. Heppell & Wines both very popular picks, newman and lucas pretty out there.

Essentially the same price, am purely interested in which combo you think will be better SC value!

Have been watching Lucas for a while, first round draft pick a while back, playing in the middle at the blues, was very impressive last night (leading possessions for the blues I think from memory with 30+... also scored v highly) but don't wanna read too much into a NAB game... also JS a worry - will probably get a gig r1 after last night but if he spuds it up... :S. Newman I really like running off the wing at $412k, think he will definitely score more than what he's priced at which is obviously SC gold, much prefer him to the likes of yaz, atley etc... has a v high disposal efficiency and is an elite finisher when he gets the chance (as we saw in NAB)

Still, probably leaning towards the other option at this stage, had Heppell last year and he was pretty ordinary but looks set to do a fair bit better in the mids this year... Wines am hoping can pull a Toby Greene and defy the expensive high draft pick rookie stereotype. Looks like a future SC juggernaut. Think these two will most likely score higher but the other option could potentially generate a decent POD advantage. Thoughts?

[kfewster]

Heppel & wines for me bud.

I think Heppell will score better then newman and I think Port will give Wines a fair chance to establish himself.

From what I've seen of Wines thus far he is a clearance king with good build ready to step straight into seniors. If they play him solely in the guts I expect him to score 70+ most games.

[Benus]

Heppel & wines for me bud.

I think Heppell will score better then newman and I think Port will give Wines a fair chance to establish himself.

From what I've seen of Wines thus far he is a clearance king with good build ready to step straight into seniors. If they play him solely in the guts I expect him to score 70+ most games.

Yeah that's where my gut feeling is atm - feel like Wines could get up to $350k+

Thanks

[Colliwobblers]

i have both Lucas and Wines  :o