COTCHIN V DANGER V DELEDIO

Started by spasticnut, March 14, 2013, 03:09:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

COTCHIN V DANGER V DELEDIO 5TH MID?

Cotchin
11 (27.5%)
Dangerfield
23 (57.5%)
Deledio
6 (15%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Marstar

Deledio for me.

Proven. Consistent. Unique.

Perma Mid, aged 25. Plus he hasn't missed a game in the last 5 seasons for a total of 172 games.

There is no reason to suggest he's reached his ceiling. There is no 'excuse' for him to drop (e.g. New Captaincy pressure).

He's not going to receive any more special attention than he did 3 years ago.







quinny88

Quote from: Marstar on March 14, 2013, 10:36:11 PM
Deledio for me.

Proven. Consistent. Unique.

Perma Mid, aged 25. Plus he hasn't missed a game in the last 5 seasons for a total of 172 games.

There is no reason to suggest he's reached his ceiling. There is no 'excuse' for him to drop (e.g. New Captaincy pressure).

He's not going to receive any more special attention than he did 3 years ago.

Ah I like that word Marstar  :P

ando_10

Well said Marstar. Completely agree

Marstar

Quote from: quinny88 on March 14, 2013, 10:40:09 PM
Quote from: Marstar on March 14, 2013, 10:36:11 PM
Deledio for me.

Proven. Consistent. Unique.

Perma Mid, aged 25. Plus he hasn't missed a game in the last 5 seasons for a total of 172 games.

There is no reason to suggest he's reached his ceiling. There is no 'excuse' for him to drop (e.g. New Captaincy pressure).

He's not going to receive any more special attention than he did 3 years ago.

Ah I like that word Marstar  :P

hahaha touche :P

Colliwobblers

Brain says cotchin, gut says dangerman. voted cotch.

cotch has the upside of being able to improve more and get more outside ball if his midfield develops further (looking at you martin).

Danger already had a pretty elite midfield around him last season,but ill also improve more, just maybe not as much?

close call how can you go wrong.

other point, Cotchin doesn't share the bye with Ablett, Swan, Pendles, Beams, Watson, Murphy  where Danger does....

tor01doc

All is opinion until Colliwobblers point regarding byes - that is fact.

tbagrocks

Quote from: quinny88 on March 14, 2013, 10:05:17 PM
Tbag you reckon all the love is directed at Cotchin and theres nothing going for Dangerfield. I think you couldnt be more wrong. All I seem to hear is how great Dangerfield is! All of your carrying on must have rubbed off on a few haha
A month ago it was all Cotchin, since then I started the Dangerman campaign to counter all the Victorian bias I was hearing

Seems to me that since Mike Sheahan toped the Dangerman at 3 every spud wants him :P

quinny88

Quote from: tbagrocks on March 15, 2013, 05:51:01 AM
Quote from: quinny88 on March 14, 2013, 10:05:17 PM
Tbag you reckon all the love is directed at Cotchin and theres nothing going for Dangerfield. I think you couldnt be more wrong. All I seem to hear is how great Dangerfield is! All of your carrying on must have rubbed off on a few haha
A month ago it was all Cotchin, since then I started the Dangerman campaign to counter all the Victorian bias I was hearing

Seems to me that since Mike Sheahan toped the Dangerman at 3 every spud wants him :P

Haha yeah you're right. Well congratulations if your aim was to make every man and his dog have dangerfield and leave Cotchin as a unique haha works for me  :P

BoredSaint