Please rate my team I WILL RATE YOURS IF YOU DO

[Carltonblues5]

BACKS:   Goddard,B  Gibbs,B  Birchall,G  Vlastuin,N  Docherty,S   Colquhoun,           (S Stevenson,L Frost, J)

MIDFIELD:    Ablett,G  Watson,J  Cotchin,T  Greene,T  Moloney,B  Ball, L  Whitfield,L   Mitchell,K      (Kerridge,S O'Meara, J)

RUCKMEN:  Jacobs,S  Kreuzer,M       (Daw,M Currie,D)

FORWARDS:    Franklin,L  Johnson,S  Martin,D  Jetta,L (syd)  Kennedy,J (wc)  Varcoe,T          (Neade,J McBean,L)

Thanks dont mind any criticism and suggestions

[Samsturmfels]

Get rid of kerridge and mcbean
Better options like crouch and viney
and macaffer

[jackel82]

Im no expert mate only my 2nd year at this but you have a few unique players which can be good if it comes off or bad if they don't.
backs are good. dont know much about Vlastuin but you want to be pretty sure who ever is in D4 is going to get full games.

Mids: Greene is different, good young player hope it comes off, Ball I have wondered about but how does he get back into such a great midfield?, Whitfield looks the goods but many go wines as he is cheeper.

Rucks: Kreuzer still waiting for him to live up to his potential, maybe under a new coach. gutsy but good option

forwards
Martin a bit inconsistent but I see why many choose him lots of talent, Jetta great player can score big, but sometimes doesn't even though he plays very well, that's the problem with super he can get 5 possessions in a game that turn the tide yet a small score. Learnt that last year not all great players score well in super. 

The players I didnt comment on are all very solid in my opinion. rookies will sort themselves rd 1

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74002.0.html
cheers