Mid Under $555,000 as (M4-5)

[blues boy]

Who would you want in your team considering i already have M. Murphy

B. Stanton                                           J.P. Kennedy
S. Thompson                                        S. Mitchell
S. Sidebottom                                       S. Selwood
S. Tuck                                                R. O'Keefe
J. Redden                                             J. Mcveigh
J. Selwood                                           N. Fyfe         
A. Swallow
P. Dangerfield

Surely the answer is there somewhere!! Who would you pick and why?

[Windigo]

Stanton, Redden, Selwood or Danger I reckon.

Most of these could/will end up being keepers unlike the lesser choices...

[Toga]

Stanton, Thompson, or Tuck.

Stanton for the inconsistent but high-scoring player.

Thompson will average the most, a bit more consistent and will improve this year imo as teams turn their attention to Danger.

Tuck for a nice POD, will never get attention from opposition given his teammates and has a huge ceiling.

[blues boy]

Stanton, Redden, Selwood or Danger I reckon.

Most of these could/will end up being keepers unlike the lesser choices...

If you had to choose one? Stanton or J. Selwood?

[Windigo]

Stanton..But Jelwood is a better player than what he showed last year. A good POD.

[tbagrocks]

Joel and Marc killed me last year, willing to give Marc another go

The Dangerman! Is going to a new level this year ;)

[blues boy]

Joel and Marc killed me last year, willing to give Marc another go

The Dangerman! Is going to a new level this year ;)

Thompson will average the most, a bit more consistent and will improve this year imo as teams turn their attention to Danger.

He may go to a new level but that will defiantly bring on the number 1 tagger from the opposition! I agree with toga here that will free up thompson

[Toga]

Oops missed Dangerman. Reckon he will also be good this year but I reckon Scotty T will just about be a better choice - pretty unique and should be consistently big this season.

[blues boy]

Would it be worth it dropping T. Cloke to Varcoe and then i could get Lids and J. Roughead instead of T. Bellchambers

[tbagrocks]

Am tempted by Thommo, should be freed up by Sloane and Dangerman, a solid 108/112 for Thommo

[Toga]

Would it be worth it dropping T. Cloke to Varcoe and then i could get Lids and J. Roughead instead of T. Bellchambers

What forward is cloke for you atm? F4/F5?

[blues boy]

Would it be worth it dropping T. Cloke to Varcoe and then i could get Lids and J. Roughead instead of T. Bellchambers

What forward is cloke for you atm? F4/F5?

F4 it would mean i would have P. Karnezis (F4) and Varcoe (F5) too risky?

[Ricochet]

Stanton will go 115+ this year

[Toga]

Would it be worth it dropping T. Cloke to Varcoe and then i could get Lids and J. Roughead instead of T. Bellchambers

What forward is cloke for you atm? F4/F5?

F4 it would mean i would have P. Karnezis (F4) and Varcoe (F5) too risky?

Hmm I guess you can look at it this  way:

Cloke (92) + Stanton (108) + Bellchambers (92)     =192

vs

Varcoe (73) + Deledio (112) + Roughead (95)        =180



I'd probably stick with Cloke & Belly and grab one of Thompson/Stanton/Dangerfield...

[blues boy]

Would it be worth it dropping T. Cloke to Varcoe and then i could get Lids and J. Roughead instead of T. Bellchambers

What forward is cloke for you atm? F4/F5?

F4 it would mean i would have P. Karnezis (F4) and Varcoe (F5) too risky?

Hmm I guess you can look at it this  way:

Cloke (92) + Stanton (108) + Bellchambers (92)     =192

vs

Varcoe (73) + Deledio (112) + Roughead (95)        =180



I'd probably stick with Cloke & Belly and grab one of Thompson/Stanton/Dangerfield...

Really think Cloke will average 92? A KPP not very reliable or is he?