Defender Poll

[Junkitup]

I want one of these guys but dont know who. I have a list of pros and cons for all of them and still cant decided  :o

[Vincent]

duffield because he will score the most lol

[Ricochet]

Hanley because of his easy early draw

[Jukes]

Hanley: 89
Duffield: 87
Shaw: 89
HH: 90

considered...

Heppell: 96

?

[Junkitup]

duffield because he will score the most lol

You say this but you didnt vote  ???

Hanley: 89
Duffield: 87
Shaw: 89
HH: 90

considered...

Heppell: 96

?

Already in

[Football Factory]

Order of preference..

Hartlett but his hammy could go twang

Shaw but he might do something stupid like put $5 on himself to kick the first goal

Hanley .threatens to breakout ..like Rico says Brisbane have a good draw

Duffield ..scored well towards the end of the year after being dropped previously

[GoLions]

IMO: Hartlett>Hanley=Duffield>Shaw

[Jukes]

duffield because he will score the most lol

You say this but you didnt vote  ???

Hanley: 89
Duffield: 87
Shaw: 89
HH: 90

considered...

Heppell: 96

?

Already in

Would go with HH then.

[owenbond007]

Duffman on pre-season form and also the way he finished 2012.

Hartlett and hanley prob be solid but cant see much more than a 80-85 average.

And shaw can be inconsistent at times as his role regularly changes depending on the opposition.

[POK252]

Hartlett.

However you say you have Heppell and I assume Goddard and Gibbs as well. I'd rethink going with 4 premiums as to me it weakens other spots on the ground.

[tbagrocks]

Hamish Hartlett simply because he is the better player here and should run through the midfield

[owenbond007]

Stick to 4 premos mate it actually weakens your team playing 3 rookies on field. The fact of the matter is the defenders as rookies will be struggling to score/ave 60 more likely scores of 50ish.

[GoLions]

Stick to 4 premos mate it actually weakens your team playing 3 rookies on field. The fact of the matter is the defenders as rookies will be struggling to score/ave 60 more likely scores of 50ish.

I'd rather 150 from a forward prem and a defender roookie than 100 from a back premo and a forward rookie who isn't going to get a game.

[owenbond007]

I didnt say load your forward line with rookies did I ?

Id rather play a midfield rookie with strong JS who will make cash faster and score more than a defender rookie who will score less and I feel all the back rookies have a stronger possibility of being vested. 

[GoLions]

I didnt say load your forward line with rookies did I ?

Id rather play a midfield rookie with strong JS who will make cash faster and score more than a defender rookie who will score less and I feel all the back rookies have a stronger possibility of being vested. 

I never said you did, but the fact is, you really don't want any forward rookies on the field (not including macaffer as a rookie btw). And I would rather take a combo such as Mundy and Pittard than something like Hartlett and Lonergan. Just my opinion though, you're free to do what you feel is best for your team.