DEF Structure

Started by essendon2, March 09, 2013, 12:36:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What's your set up in DEF?

3-0-0-3
4-0-0-3
3-1-0-2
4-1-0-2
3-0-1-2
4-0-1-1
5-0-0-1

essendon2

a bit like my Top 6 polls, there'll be one a day on each line-of-field's structure. this is actually annoying the shower out of me because everytime I fiddle with my team I change the structure but end up with the same amount of scoring potential.

Here's how the poll works:
(Def)

ÃœBER PREMO = 400k+ (Theee G's/Heppell/Hartlett)
PREMO = 330-400k (Watts/Hibberd/Pearce)
MID-PRICE = 200-330k (Atley/Harbrow/Russell/Tambling)
ROOK = sub 200k (Vlastuin/Pittard/Goodes)

Toga

I'm exactly the same e2... Constantly changing the structure but doesn't really change the scoring potential at all :-X

At the moment my backline is the 4-0-0-3 structure:

Goddard, Gibbs, Heppell, Hartlett, Pittard, Goodes (Terlich, Stevenson)      -Vlastuin in the mids.


BUT that has been changing on a daily basis with the 3-0-0-4 structure, which includes Goddard, Gibbs and Stanley/Hartlett..

For the moment I'm pretty set on the four uber premo approach though.. Hartlett and Heppell just look too good to pass up!

essendon2

Quote from: Toga on March 09, 2013, 12:49:52 PM
I'm exactly the same e2... Constantly changing the structure but doesn't really change the scoring potential at all :-X

At the moment my backline is the 4-0-0-3 structure:

Goddard, Gibbs, Heppell, Hartlett, Pittard, Goodes (Terlich, Stevenson)      -Vlastuin in the mids.


BUT that has been changing on a daily basis with the 3-0-0-4 structure, which includes Goddard, Gibbs and Stanley/Hartlett..

For the moment I'm pretty set on the four uber premo approach though.. Hartlett and Heppell just look too good to pass up!
that's the thing.. I really want both Heppell and Hartlett because I can't split the two

-but if I have 4 guns in DEF, i can't have the 5 gun mids as well!
and even if I have 5 gun mids with 3 gun DEF, it's almost impossible to have a rookie-less FWD (Macaffer is counted as a rook)

Toga

Yeah, exactly my dilemma mate... Atm I have 4 UP defenders, 4 UP midfielders, and Macaffer as the only rookie on field up forwards ::)

I reckon that's the way to go, although I wouldn't mind having ONE more fwd rook that I can rely on :-X

jhawk



I started with 4 premo last year and thought it was where I went wrong .
I think there both good options not sure if I would have two of them . will the ave 100 + or stay 85-95.

if your hell bent on having both why not have have goddard/gibbs  hartlett heppel .

use goodard n gibbs both locks but do u have to start with them both cant see there price rising that much 20 k ? tops
why not use that to have extra premo in mid which will ave u 120 plus ?

Football Factory

You have to go weak somewhere or go with plenty of midpricers .. ive decided after much thought that the backline will be where i take my risk .. im going with 3 0 0 3  there is plenty of good rooks in the backline this year and i think ill take advantage of this.

Artax

Not alone there FF I think that is where the "safest risks" lie

pommyadam

Vlast and Goodes alongside 4 uber-premo's for me

GM

Quote from: Toga on March 09, 2013, 01:06:13 PM
Yeah, exactly my dilemma mate... Atm I have 4 UP defenders, 4 UP midfielders, and Macaffer as the only rookie on field up forwards ::)

I reckon that's the way to go, although I wouldn't mind having ONE more fwd rook that I can rely on :-X
Neade atm is the only one close to starting R1.T.Lee unlikely unless he shows something special today.

powersuperkents

My backline is locked at

Goddard, Stanley, Gibbs, Birchall, Pittard, Goodes, Docherty, Terlich

Toga

Aaaand I've changed again. Downgrading Heppell to Vlastuin is the only way I can get Ablett in my mids and a 200K~ish fwd :-X

GM

Quote from: Toga on March 09, 2013, 03:37:35 PM
Aaaand I've changed again. Downgrading Heppell to Vlastuin is the only way I can get Ablett in my mids and a 200K~ish fwd :-X
use hartlett?

Toga

Would you prefer having Heppell or Hartlett in your team? ???

GM

Quote from: Toga on March 09, 2013, 03:42:51 PM
Would you prefer having Heppell or Hartlett in your team? ???
I probably have Hep atm for durability reasons.

Toga

Yeah that's true he is a lot more durable... Imo they'll probably average around the same, not sure who has a higher cieling though...

Heppy looked massive yesterday till he was subbed! :o