Who to pick Karnezis or Varcoe

[Nails]

Neither really impress me, I can't see Varcoe getting enough of the ball to be a good selection. Karnezis is still young and I wouldn't be comfortable picking him.

Wonder how many didn't pick Sidebum simply because he was young :o

[Holz]

Neither really impress me, I can't see Varcoe getting enough of the ball to be a good selection. Karnezis is still young and I wouldn't be comfortable picking him.

Wonder how many didn't pick Sidebum simply because he was young :o

while i have karnezis i think thats a pretty unfair comparison, i was 100% comfoortable with sidey last year. Karnezis could get dropped, subbed, pump out 60s who knows.

[Vincent]

Varcoe has shown he is a good player at AFL level. Karnezis has played good nab cup games and thats all so far

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Karnezis isn't a regular yet you can't compare him to Sidey last year.

[Justin Bieber]

Neither really impress me, I can't see Varcoe getting enough of the ball to be a good selection. Karnezis is still young and I wouldn't be comfortable picking him.

Wonder how many didn't pick Sidebum simply because he was young :o

Yeah that was a horrible call. Sidebottom had a 85 ave in 2011 then increase in 2012. Karnesiz has a 2012 ave of like 50.

[Nails]

Everyone is missing the main point though

Cornelius > Karnezis.

[henry]

Karnezis has got himself a spot for me too, had byrnes over varcoe originally but now Karny. Hopefully it pays off!