Ask Jayman

[specky92]

Minson or Goldstein?

And

Can the friend zone be broken? ;)

[Jay]

Just a quick one jayman...

Backline consists of Goddard, Gibbs, Hanley, hartlett, goodes, vlastuin, Clarke and thurlow
Just need someone else's thoughts on whether its time to part ways with one of goodes or vlastuin for birchall, as it won't cost much at all for goodes and nothing for vlas...so which one if I go the straight swap?

I think Goodes --> Birch is an awesome move. Birch is cheap now and is a proven premium. I think Goodes has pretty much peaked. Good move!

Vlast has been pumping out as good backline scoring numbers as you get this year! Too early to trade him.

[Jay]

Hi Jayman,

I'm thinking Outside the box this week.


My team:
Def: Goddard, Shaw, Gibbs, Birchall, Goodes, Vlaustin (Brown, Thurlow)
Mid: Ablett, Pendlebury, Swan, Dangerfield, Cotchin, JP Kennedy, Watson, Mitchell (Martin, Crouch)
Ruc: Cox, Maric (Nicholls, Rowe)
Fwd: Naitinui, Johnson, Rockliff, Franklin, JK Kennedy, Macaffer (Staker, B. Kennedy)

With 10 trades left, I'm looking at trades that will finish my team rather than get myself out of trouble this week.  So this week, taking advantage of three trades I thought:
JK Kennedy to Bartel
Macaffer to Daniher
Crouch to D. Martin

Then next week I swap Martin for B. Kennedy giving me a dpp link between my mids and my forwards, and trade Thurlow to Oxley to give the dpp to Staker.  At should leave me 6 trades and $150-$180k in my bank to turn Vlaustin into Hanley/Heppell/Hibberd when they bottom out and Martin/Mitchell/ B Kennedy into a premium, with the added option of Rowe to McBean if I need extra cash.

Toovey to hear your thoughts on this.

All solid moves - go with your gut but make sure you watch out on your trades. The General always hits late in the year.... You going for league or overall?

[Jay]

i'm finishing up the midfield but im a bit stuck on who i should get as my last premo.
looking for a decent mid $530 or under

im thinking Cornes or Selwood.
both are similarly priced.

Cotchin - 8 Tons in 10 games, low 76
Cornes - 8 Tons, low 73 (yes i know they're usually against bottom sides)
Selwood - 6 Tons, low 73

If you're thinking Cornes or Selwood then would definitely go Selwood (Joel?) Cornes is a star but I just feel Selwood is more likely to pump out the bigger scores later in the year.

[Jay]

I only answer sporting related questions, specky.

Minson or Goldstein?

Would go Goldstein, Minson was poor last weekend and is set to take a fair price whack over the coming weeks. As I have said before, it would be wise to go Goldstein if it has to be done this week. Goldy is as good of a ruck scorer as there is, get him and ya won't regret. Not saying Minson is a bad choice though, just not a wise move to bring him in this week.

[Nige]

What does it take to make you check your messages? :(

Also, a bonus question which actually is Supercoach related...

Is it worth going a forward like Dusty or Stevie J as captain or should I give it to one of my mids in K-Jack, Barlow, Griff or Priddis?

[Jay]

What does it take to make you check your messages? :(

Also, a bonus question which actually is Supercoach related...

Is it worth going a forward like Dusty or Stevie J as captain or should I give it to one of my mids in K-Jack, Barlow, Griff or Priddis?

$100 through paypal would do quite nicely :P

yay, Supercoach!

Advantages of having the loophole mate! I would go Jack VC into Griff C.

[Nige]

What does it take to make you check your messages? :(

Also, a bonus question which actually is Supercoach related...

Is it worth going a forward like Dusty or Stevie J as captain or should I give it to one of my mids in K-Jack, Barlow, Griff or Priddis?

$100 through paypal would do quite nicely :P

yay, Supercoach!

Advantages of having the loophole mate! I would go Jack VC into Griff C.

Yeah no, I don't haveth da moneyz.

And if one doesn't like the loophole?

[Jay]

What does it take to make you check your messages? :(

Also, a bonus question which actually is Supercoach related...

Is it worth going a forward like Dusty or Stevie J as captain or should I give it to one of my mids in K-Jack, Barlow, Griff or Priddis?

$100 through paypal would do quite nicely :P

yay, Supercoach!

Advantages of having the loophole mate! I would go Jack VC into Griff C.

Yeah no, I don't haveth da moneyz.

And if one doesn't like the loophole?

Then you have little chance of winning anything :P Go Griff captain mate, but man the loophole is awesome.

[Nige]

What does it take to make you check your messages? :(

Also, a bonus question which actually is Supercoach related...

Is it worth going a forward like Dusty or Stevie J as captain or should I give it to one of my mids in K-Jack, Barlow, Griff or Priddis?

$100 through paypal would do quite nicely :P

yay, Supercoach!

Advantages of having the loophole mate! I would go Jack VC into Griff C.

Yeah no, I don't haveth da moneyz.

And if one doesn't like the loophole?

Then you have little chance of winning anything :P Go Griff captain mate, but man the loophole is awesome.

I've got it on K-Jack atm, I'll switch it over though. If it doesn't work out, it's on you.  :P

[jrmoo]

Jayman
Your thoughts on who's best to bring into my mids. Currently have
Ablett, Swan, Sloane, Swallow, Priddis, O'meara, Vlastuin, t.Mitchell, martin, Hrovat.

Was thinking of JPK for Omeara.
Next week Vlastuin to Watson
and Pendles down the track

Any tips would be great
Cheers

[Jay]

Jayman
Your thoughts on who's best to bring into my mids. Currently have
Ablett, Swan, Sloane, Swallow, Priddis, O'meara, Vlastuin, t.Mitchell, martin, Hrovat.

Was thinking of JPK for Omeara.
Next week Vlastuin to Watson
and Pendles down the track

Any tips would be great
Cheers

Pendles after his bye should be the first priority.

Think JPK/Jobe can be your last couple of mid upgrades, but Pendles is a must.

[Jester]

Need some advice Jayman. I currently have O'Meara (M7), Viney (M8), Crouch (M9) and B.Kennedy (M10 with DPP). Next week i hope to bring Danger or Watson into the fold too. Note: 12 trades remain.

Q1) Who should T.Michell replace?

Q2) Is it worth replacing another for Hrovat or best to save the trade for now?

[tor01doc]

.

[Jay]

Still waiting to see Lebron BEING THE REASON his team wins a title. Has not done it yet. Role players and refs have bailed him out the past 2 seasons.

17 > 3

Go Boston.