Ask Jayman

[Keeper27]

trading out Pittard & Hutchins.
which 2 of these guys should I get?

Dixon, Hibberd, shaw.

or should I cop 1 donut this week (keep Pittard) and trade Fyfe out for Ablett?

[Jester]

Trade one - I like the look of Gawn's scores and he may be a good long term option as R4. So I will go Blicvas > Gawn.

Trade two - I have a couple of holes in my backline but am reluctant to trade. If I did trade I would look at outing Pittard ... I do not have enough to upgrade him to a premo so it would be sideways to Terlich or down to Vlastuin (one week too early IMO) ... not great options this week so I think I will wear the donut and play the long game.

I would be interested in your thoughts Jayman.

[Bennyy]

I'm thinking Blicavs to Gawn
Dwyer to Stevie J

Good trades to do or pulling the pin too early? Thoughts?

[Jay]

Got big issues this week - what trades to make? Will put in bold the players who aren't playing this week (that we already know of):

DEF: Goddard, Birchall, Stevenson, Terlich, Docherty, Goodes (Gibbs, Pittard)
MID: Pendlebury, Ablett, Mundy, Cotchin, Wines, O'Meara, K Stevens, Viney (Fyfe, Crouch)
RUC: Jacobs, Leuenberger (Blicavs, Rowe)
FWD: Cox, JJ Kennedy, Bartel, Rockliff, Neade, Dwyer (Walker, T Lee)

What two trades would you make this week? Originally was looking to dump Blicavs for Gawn as a cash cow, but is that out of the question now with the defense troubles and Walker's season being over? If I trade out a defender, which one should go?

Pittard to Vlastuin

and

Walker to Steve Johnson. Can you afford that? If not, just any premium will do :)

[Jay]

backline problem

Goddard,Gibbs*, Heppell*, Grimes, Goodes*, Heath (Pittard* and Terlich)

copping two 0s if I don't trade, only have 1k in bank. what should I do?

Pittard and Gibbs --> Vlastuin and a premium. Who you keen on?

[Jay]

rate these backline options jay, now that heppel is gone.

Hibberd 102 this year 74 last year

Grimes 100 this year 88 last year

Shaw 90 this year 100 last year

Waters 97 this year 100 last year.

1. Beau Waters
2. Heath Shaw
3. Jack Grimes
4. Michael Hibberd

[Jay]

trading out Pittard & Hutchins.
which 2 of these guys should I get?

Dixon, Hibberd, shaw.

or should I cop 1 donut this week (keep Pittard) and trade Fyfe out for Ablett?

Dont cop the donut mate. Take Hibberd and Shaw :)

[Jay]

Trade one - I like the look of Gawn's scores and he may be a good long term option as R4. So I will go Blicvas > Gawn.

Trade two - I have a couple of holes in my backline but am reluctant to trade. If I did trade I would look at outing Pittard ... I do not have enough to upgrade him to a premo so it would be sideways to Terlich or down to Vlastuin (one week too early IMO) ... not great options this week so I think I will wear the donut and play the long game.

I would be interested in your thoughts Jayman.

Dont get Terlich mate, missed that boat. Take Vlastuin, showed some signs on the weekend and although risky js, at least he is playing! :D

[Jay]

I'm thinking Blicavs to Gawn
Dwyer to Stevie J

Good trades to do or pulling the pin too early? Thoughts?

Great trades. Flawless mate.

SJ is a proven gun and Gawn seems to be a cash cow with great js. Blicavs and Dwyer are pretty much done imo

[Bentekezzz]

backline problem

Goddard,Gibbs*, Heppell*, Grimes, Goodes*, Heath (Pittard* and Terlich)

copping two 0s if I don't trade, only have 1k in bank. what should I do?

Pittard and Gibbs --> Vlastuin and a premium. Who you keen on?

could get anyone besides birch in, quite keen on scotland or hartlett

[Jay]

backline problem

Goddard,Gibbs*, Heppell*, Grimes, Goodes*, Heath (Pittard* and Terlich)

copping two 0s if I don't trade, only have 1k in bank. what should I do?

Pittard and Gibbs --> Vlastuin and a premium. Who you keen on?

could get anyone besides birch in, quite keen on scotland or hartlett

Hartlett for sure! :D

[Bentekezzz]

backline problem

Goddard,Gibbs*, Heppell*, Grimes, Goodes*, Heath (Pittard* and Terlich)

copping two 0s if I don't trade, only have 1k in bank. what should I do?

Pittard and Gibbs --> Vlastuin and a premium. Who you keen on?

could get anyone besides birch in, quite keen on scotland or hartlett

Hartlett for sure! :D

do u think gibbs is being rested just because hes playing melbourne or its an actual hammy?

[Jay]

backline problem

Goddard,Gibbs*, Heppell*, Grimes, Goodes*, Heath (Pittard* and Terlich)

copping two 0s if I don't trade, only have 1k in bank. what should I do?

Pittard and Gibbs --> Vlastuin and a premium. Who you keen on?

could get anyone besides birch in, quite keen on scotland or hartlett

Hartlett for sure! :D

do u think gibbs is being rested just because hes playing melbourne or its an actual hammy?

I think he will be back for Round 7. Just a gut feeling

[Big Mac]

Is it worth trading out Pittard for Saunders now? Or wait to choose someone next week, potentially missing out on one of Kent/Lamb/Kennedy/Lonergan.

[Jay]

Is it worth trading out Pittard for Saunders now? Or wait to choose someone next week, potentially missing out on one of Kent/Lamb/Kennedy/Lonergan.

Id wait a week and get Vlastuin... Laird or Doch might return next week ;)