Ask Jayman

[Jay]

I'm thinking of trading out Luke Brown and Ben Howlett for Michael Evans and a mid premo.
Which mid premo would you pick? (I can afford any) or would you hold onto Brown and Howlett?

Getting in Evans is the obvious move, almost a must imo. Keep Howlett, you picked him for a reason and has performed well to yet.

Could you do Brown to Evans?

Thanks for the advice mate
Yeah I could do Brown to Evans by swapping Goodes into def

Great. I would do that then!

[Jroo]

Hey Jay what are your thoughts on this
Blicavs for Knights?
Forwards are then
Cox, Dusty, Rocky, Monfries, Knights, Dwyer (Macaffer, Neade)

You're the Tiges man so if you think Knights will play plenty of games and score well then go for it. Needs to make cash to become an easy swap to a prem. or even a keeper.

Blicavs is pretty much done. But how does your ruck cover look with him gone?

Cheers for the response Jay.
Rucks are Jacobs, Berger then Rowe and Daw on the pine.

Thats all good. Daw is good cover and Rowe + Cox. Go with your gut :)

I'm not sure.
Knights could spud it up and I'll have to waste a trade and get him out.
I could bring in Mayes instead

[Jay]

Hey Jay what are your thoughts on this
Blicavs for Knights?
Forwards are then
Cox, Dusty, Rocky, Monfries, Knights, Dwyer (Macaffer, Neade)

You're the Tiges man so if you think Knights will play plenty of games and score well then go for it. Needs to make cash to become an easy swap to a prem. or even a keeper.

Blicavs is pretty much done. But how does your ruck cover look with him gone?

Cheers for the response Jay.
Rucks are Jacobs, Berger then Rowe and Daw on the pine.

Thats all good. Daw is good cover and Rowe + Cox. Go with your gut :)

I'm not sure.
Knights could spud it up and I'll have to waste a trade and get him out.
I could bring in Mayes instead

Comes down to whether you think Knights can make enough cash or if he can become a keeper. If not take the safe option and go Mayes

[tor01doc]

What would you do if your basketball team were outscored 48 - 81 in second half play over 2 games?  ;)

Go on, tell me to Knick off if you like.

[Jay]

What would you do if your basketball team were outscored 48 - 81 in second half play over 2 games?  ;)

Go on, tell me to Knick off if you like.

Hahahahahahah. Oh Doc, that hit a nerve man :(

Good one. We deserve that!

Doesn't look like the same Celtics out there. Our big men are like ghosts - no presence. Jason Terry promised us a championship and has done squat :o

Avery looks lost on offense, cant get his own shot and is a bad passer. BRING BACK RONDO :'(

Watch us defend our home-court in the next couple of games and put the pressure right back on the 'superstar' that has the worst playoff winning percentage ever.... ;)

[tor01doc]

Strikers or Dolphins, Strikers or Dolphins?

I'll go Dolphins.

Good luck.

[Jay]

Strikers or Dolphins, Strikers or Dolphins?

I'll go Dolphins.

Good luck.

A multi on the Strikers and Celtics to win! :D

[j]

I'm hoping you can help me out. I just traded Ablett in and got rid of gaff, with one more trade left should I - get rid of Viney for Evans, or get rid of k Mitchell for Evans, or get rid of T Walker for Cloke, or get rid of T Walker for franklin, or get rid of Tom lee/Macaffer for Mayes. I can't choose the priority, what do you think?

[Jay]

I'm hoping you can help me out. I just traded Ablett in and got rid of gaff, with one more trade left should I - get rid of Viney for Evans, or get rid of k Mitchell for Evans, or get rid of T Walker for Cloke, or get rid of T Walker for franklin, or get rid of Tom lee/Macaffer for Mayes. I can't choose the priority, what do you think?

Out of those options I would trade Kane Mitchell to Evans. He is not on the senior list anymore so wont play any games presuming port have no LTIs. All our rookies need to be making cash, and he wont be. Trade him - Evans is the perfect choice

[j]

I'm hoping you can help me out. I just traded Ablett in and got rid of gaff, with one more trade left should I - get rid of Viney for Evans, or get rid of k Mitchell for Evans, or get rid of T Walker for Cloke, or get rid of T Walker for franklin, or get rid of Tom lee/Macaffer for Mayes. I can't choose the priority, what do you think?

Out of those options I would trade Kane Mitchell to Evans. He is not on the senior list anymore so wont play any games presuming port have no LTIs. All our rookies need to be making cash, and he wont be. Trade him - Evans is the perfect choice

Would it be more important to get Evans in over Mayes? If iget Evans in I'll have both him and Viney on my bench

[Jay]

I'm hoping you can help me out. I just traded Ablett in and got rid of gaff, with one more trade left should I - get rid of Viney for Evans, or get rid of k Mitchell for Evans, or get rid of T Walker for Cloke, or get rid of T Walker for franklin, or get rid of Tom lee/Macaffer for Mayes. I can't choose the priority, what do you think?

Out of those options I would trade Kane Mitchell to Evans. He is not on the senior list anymore so wont play any games presuming port have no LTIs. All our rookies need to be making cash, and he wont be. Trade him - Evans is the perfect choice

Would it be more important to get Evans in over Mayes? If iget Evans in I'll have both him and Viney on my bench

Yes. Evans will make more cash and quicker.

[j]

I'm hoping you can help me out. I just traded Ablett in and got rid of gaff, with one more trade left should I - get rid of Viney for Evans, or get rid of k Mitchell for Evans, or get rid of T Walker for Cloke, or get rid of T Walker for franklin, or get rid of Tom lee/Macaffer for Mayes. I can't choose the priority, what do you think?

Out of those options I would trade Kane Mitchell to Evans. He is not on the senior list anymore so wont play any games presuming port have no LTIs. All our rookies need to be making cash, and he wont be. Trade him - Evans is the perfect choice

Would it be more important to get Evans in over Mayes? If iget Evans in I'll have both him and Viney on my bench

Yes. Evans will make more cash and quicker.

Ok thanks mate

[Big Mac]

I'm trading Hill to Evans this week. But what should I do with the other trade, Macaffer to Mayes or Duffield to Birchall/Hartlett?

[Donnie Brasco]

What should I do mate, Viney to Evans? Anything else? Thanks!


http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,75720.15.html

[Rooboys_18]

This one is really doing my head in. Should I trade Viney or Brown to Evans?
Cheers