Ask Jayman

[JMAN23]

Should i trade out Brad Hill to Rampe/Evans to make enough money for Duffield to Birchall? Thanks :)

[Keeper27]

Should i trade out Brad Hill to Rampe/Evans to make enough money for Duffield to Birchall? Thanks :)

Evans kicked 3 goals in the last quarter in a tight game, then again Hill doesnt have much more money to make.

[Big Mac]

Hey, i'm not sure if I should be trading Hill to Mayes, and then leaving Duffield alone or maybe trading to Hartlett, or trading Hill to Kerridge, and then trading Duffield to Birchall. What are your thoughts?

P.S. I've also got Macaffer as well if you would care to impart some wisdom :)

[Jay]

Should i trade out Brad Hill to Rampe/Evans to make enough money for Duffield to Birchall? Thanks :)

Yes. Hill doesn't have huge dollars to make anymore. Evans, although his average may be inflated a little, will make a shower load of cash. Any player with a -100 b/e is pretty much a must IMO.

Duff has disappointed and seems to be a shadow of his former self. Look to trade to Hartlett or like you say, Birchall. Although I see teams starting to give Birch a lot more attention...

[Noz]

My forward line is Bartel, Rocky, Zorko, Martin, Kennedy and Lecras with Dwyer and Neade on the bench
My midfield line is Ablett, Swan, Pendles, Lids, Hannebery, JOM, Wines, Crouch with Hill and Kommer on the bench

Should i downgrade Neade and Hill to Evans and Mayes but than that would leave me with 23 trades and only want to use 1 really this week.

[Keeper27]

do you really need the money that badly?
if not don't trade.

if you do then only make one trade. Dywer.
with a few Collingwood guns coming back I can see that he'll get limited time.
Neade will keep making you money.
you can ride out Viney's 9 and will start making money again in a few weeks.

sorry for butting in Jayman. just wanted to help.

on a side note what have you done with the rest of your trades??

[Noz]

do you really need the money that badly?
if not don't trade.

if you do then only make one trade. Dywer.
with a few Collingwood guns coming back I can see that he'll get limited time.
Neade will keep making you money.
you can ride out Viney's 9 and will start making money again in a few weeks.

sorry for butting in Jayman. just wanted to help.

on a side note what have you done with the rest of your trades??

Is this too me? Cause i don't have Viney

Longer to Leuey
Docherty - Brown
Caf - Lecras
Whitfield - Crouch
Karnezis - Dwyer

are my other trades.

[Rooboys_18]

I'm thinking of trading out Luke Brown and Ben Howlett for Michael Evans and a mid premo.
Which mid premo would you pick? (I can afford any) or would you hold onto Brown and Howlett?

[Jay]

My forward line is Bartel, Rocky, Zorko, Martin, Kennedy and Lecras with Dwyer and Neade on the bench
My midfield line is Ablett, Swan, Pendles, Lids, Hannebery, JOM, Wines, Crouch with Hill and Kommer on the bench

Should i downgrade Neade and Hill to Evans and Mayes but than that would leave me with 23 trades and only want to use 1 really this week.

Yeah good move if in search for quick cash. I'd just do Hill to Evans though. Neade still has more cash to make and Mayes is quite pricey. So yeah, just do the 1 mate :)

[Jroo]

Hey Jay what are your thoughts on this
Blicavs for Knights?
Forwards are then
Cox, Dusty, Rocky, Monfries, Knights, Dwyer (Macaffer, Neade)

[Jay]

I'm thinking of trading out Luke Brown and Ben Howlett for Michael Evans and a mid premo.
Which mid premo would you pick? (I can afford any) or would you hold onto Brown and Howlett?

Getting in Evans is the obvious move, almost a must imo. Keep Howlett, you picked him for a reason and has performed well to yet.

Could you do Brown to Evans?

[Jay]

Hey Jay what are your thoughts on this
Blicavs for Knights?
Forwards are then
Cox, Dusty, Rocky, Monfries, Knights, Dwyer (Macaffer, Neade)

You're the Tiges man so if you think Knights will play plenty of games and score well then go for it. Needs to make cash to become an easy swap to a prem. or even a keeper.

Blicavs is pretty much done. But how does your ruck cover look with him gone?

[Jroo]

Hey Jay what are your thoughts on this
Blicavs for Knights?
Forwards are then
Cox, Dusty, Rocky, Monfries, Knights, Dwyer (Macaffer, Neade)

You're the Tiges man so if you think Knights will play plenty of games and score well then go for it. Needs to make cash to become an easy swap to a prem. or even a keeper.

Blicavs is pretty much done. But how does your ruck cover look with him gone?

Cheers for the response Jay.
Rucks are Jacobs, Berger then Rowe and Daw on the pine.

[Rooboys_18]

I'm thinking of trading out Luke Brown and Ben Howlett for Michael Evans and a mid premo.
Which mid premo would you pick? (I can afford any) or would you hold onto Brown and Howlett?

Getting in Evans is the obvious move, almost a must imo. Keep Howlett, you picked him for a reason and has performed well to yet.

Could you do Brown to Evans?

Thanks for the advice mate
Yeah I could do Brown to Evans by swapping Goodes into def

[Jay]

Hey Jay what are your thoughts on this
Blicavs for Knights?
Forwards are then
Cox, Dusty, Rocky, Monfries, Knights, Dwyer (Macaffer, Neade)

You're the Tiges man so if you think Knights will play plenty of games and score well then go for it. Needs to make cash to become an easy swap to a prem. or even a keeper.

Blicavs is pretty much done. But how does your ruck cover look with him gone?

Cheers for the response Jay.
Rucks are Jacobs, Berger then Rowe and Daw on the pine.

Thats all good. Daw is good cover and Rowe + Cox. Go with your gut :)