Ask Jayman

[jeesh]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,78049.0.html

[Jay]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,78049.0.html

I already voted for Rowe

[Sausage_Roll35]

Hi Jayman,

Thanks for your continual advice! Question for you -

174k Cash Remaining

M: Pendles, Ablett, Selwood, Danger, Fyfe, Wines, Viney, O'Meara .... Neade, Kommer
R: Jacobs, Rowe .... Blicavs, Currie
F: Cox, Franklin, Bartel, Zorko, LeCras, Dwyer .... Macaffer, Lee

My thought process is to swap Zorko to mids via Neade then Zorko > Couch, then Currie > Leuenberger leaving me 355k ...

What you reckon? Some better options I could be looking at?

Cheers

[jeesh]

I already voted for Rowe

Thanks for voting mate. Have you got an opinion as to why you think Rowe's JS is better than Sinclair's?

[Jay]

Hi Jayman,

Thanks for your continual advice! Question for you -

174k Cash Remaining

M: Pendles, Ablett, Selwood, Danger, Fyfe, Wines, Viney, O'Meara .... Neade, Kommer
R: Jacobs, Rowe .... Blicavs, Currie
F: Cox, Franklin, Bartel, Zorko, LeCras, Dwyer .... Macaffer, Lee

My thought process is to swap Zorko to mids via Neade then Zorko > Crouch, then Currie > Leuenberger leaving me 355k ...

What you reckon? Some better options I could be looking at?

Cheers

Sounds great. That is probably exactly what I would do. Crouch is a gun and Leuey is pretty much a must-have imo

[Jay]

I already voted for Rowe

Thanks for voting mate. Have you got an opinion as to why you think Rowe's JS is better than Sinclair's?

I think Kreuzer going down for a while means Rowe's spot is pretty much secured providing he doesn't spud up. Which I cant see him doing

[Keeper27]

OPTION 1

DEF - Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Hartlett, Pittard, Brown Hutchins - Stevenson/Russell
MID - Pendlebury, Kennedy, Fyfe, Swan, Mundy, Wines, O'Meara, Crouch - Kommer/Viney
RUCK - Minson, Giles Goldy - Blicavs/Daw
FWD - Cox, Bartel, JJK, Rocky, Dwyer, Neade - Macaffer/Rowe

Kitty - $537,000

Brown to Hutchins (make some money & points)
Giles to Goldy (more points)

or

OPTION 2

DEF - Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Hartlett, Pittard, Brown Birchall - Stevenson/Russell
MID - Pendlebury, Kennedy, Fyfe, Swan, Mundy, Wines, O'Meara, Crouch - Kommer/Viney
RUCK - Minson, Giles Cox - Blicavs/Daw
FWD - Cox Monfries, Bartel, JJK, Rocky, Dwyer, Neade - Macaffer/Rowe

Kitty - $226,600

Brown to Birchall (sh!tload more points)
Giles to Cox (more points)
Cox to Monfries (good form)

[jeesh]

I think Kreuzer going down for a while means Rowe's spot is pretty much secured providing he doesn't spud up. Which I cant see him doing

I just worry about Waite coming back into the side.

[KoopKicka]

I think Kreuzer going down for a while means Rowe's spot is pretty much secured providing he doesn't spud up. Which I cant see him doing

I just worry about Waite coming back into the side.

Waites still a while out isnt he?

[jeesh]

Waites still a while out isnt he?

Due back this week according to this site. Hopefully he does come back this week and if Rowe stays in it'll be happy days!

http://www.injuryupdate.com.au/afl-injury-list.php#carlton

[jeesh]

Found this at http://www.carltonfc.com.au/

CarltonFC Malthouse: "No, there's no chance Jarrad Waite will play this weekend."

[jeesh]

OPTION 1

DEF - Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Hartlett, Pittard, Brown Hutchins - Stevenson/Russell
MID - Pendlebury, Kennedy, Fyfe, Swan, Mundy, Wines, O'Meara, Crouch - Kommer/Viney
RUCK - Minson, Giles Goldy - Blicavs/Daw
FWD - Cox, Bartel, JJK, Rocky, Dwyer, Neade - Macaffer/Rowe

Kitty - $537,000

Brown to Hutchins (make some money & points)
Giles to Goldy (more points)

or

OPTION 2

DEF - Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Hartlett, Pittard, Brown Birchall - Stevenson/Russell
MID - Pendlebury, Kennedy, Fyfe, Swan, Mundy, Wines, O'Meara, Crouch - Kommer/Viney
RUCK - Minson, Giles Cox - Blicavs/Daw
FWD - Cox Monfries, Bartel, JJK, Rocky, Dwyer, Neade - Macaffer/Rowe

Kitty - $226,600

Brown to Birchall (sh!tload more points)
Giles to Cox (more points)
Cox to Monfries (good form)

I wouldn't go ahead with any of those trades. Brown did f#$k all against Port but with a score of 97 prior I'd be confident he could score alright this week against the dogs. As for your other trade I wouldn't pull the trigger on Giles just yet seeing they have Melbourne this week and the fact Brogan is suspended for 3 weeks and if Bellchambers 144 and Cox 171 are anything to go by he could be in for a massive one. If you've got the cash I would consider trading Kommer -> Franklin via subbing Dwyer to the mids. Sorry Jayman just couldn't help myself  :-X

[Keeper27]

was thinking the same thing with giles.
He's been ok and with Brogan out I'm sure he'll kill it.
Kommer to Franklin is a good idea and I've money for it.

what about Russell to Hutchins? or birchall?

[Noz]

Whitfield - Crocuh

Than which one?

Caf- Lecras
Dwyer - Robbo
Neade - Cloke

Leaving me with 25 trades left.

[jeesh]

what about Russell to Hutchins? or birchall?

Yeah might as well axe Russell if your rookies are scoring better and you've got him on the pine making little to no cash. Not a fan of Goddard?