Ask Jayman

[nightwalker_1310au]

Hey Jayman my team consists of the following:-


Royalz-With-Cheese
   
Back line: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, P.Duffield,  T.Armstrong, L.Stevenson, B.Goodes.
Reserves:
(D.Terlich, J.Frost)

Mid: G.Ablett, D.Beams,K.Jack, T.Cotchin, D.Rich, M.Duncan, J.Viney, J.O'meara
Reserves:
(N.Kommer,  K.Mitchell)

Rucks: W.Minson, M.Blicavs
Reserves:
(D.Currie, S.Rowe)

Forwards: T.Rockliff, D.Cox, M.Robinson, J.Bartel, K.Harper, P.Karnezis.
Reserves:                     
(J.Neade, B.Maccafer)

# Question is mate thinking of doing two trades and changing Armstrong to pittard as there playing Gws this week and then upgrading Harper to Siposs. What do you think and if you think I should mate and if those trades are viable or if you know of anything else I can do to alter and make my team solid. Thanks mate.

[petefisker]

Hey Jayman -

Rucks - Roughhead, Bellchambers
(bench) Daw, Blicavs

Forward -Cox

I dont know what i was thinking but wanted roughy for DPP and his average and everyone talked up Bellchambers.
I just traded both of them to Goldstein and Jacobs. (or can go Goldstein and Maric).
Loose my DPP with Cox as i dont have Row but meh..
Goldstien and Jacobs didn't play very well and stilll got 121 and 102.
Roughy played a forward pocket role with no ruch time and bellchambers only got 70 from a solid performance, so would need a miracle game ot get 110.

Thoughts?  8)

[kingy_79]

Rioli+kommer or matty wright+ b. hill/ k.stevens

[Jay]

SORRY FOR LATENESS

I selected Longer to fill the gap for Leuy while he was out. Q1) Do you think Leuy will be back this week? Q2) Even if he is back I am wondering if JJKennedy, or even Monfries, would prove a better choice at a similar price (both had solid pre-season's, runs on the board, etc). What are your thoughts Jayman?

Well Leuey is back mate and it is time for Longer to go. Him being dropped pretty much means the only logical move for you is a straight swap to Leuey and cross your fingers

[Jay]

Hi Jayman,

Wondering what you would do if you owned Dangerfield and he has another stinking under 100 game this week and Bartel struggles to get over 100 the week after. He didn't impress me at all as an owner yesterday till the last quarter. Don't want that to be happening all the time. Would Chappy have been a better choice?

I also have Franklin who was a bit average yesterday but will see how he goes next week.

Also do you think it's the wrong move already picking Swan over Pendles? I did this this year after having Pendles the last couple of years and am thinking maybe Pendles is now the better pick with having more upside maybe?

Thanking you in advance for your advice mate.  :D

If you've gone Swan over Pendles then stick by it. Both are guns and Pendles is only narrowly the better pick - don't waste the trade.

Dangerfield will come back strong, don't even think about trading him in sc imo. Guy is a jet and is one of the elite premiums hence him being priced at 636k - gotta keep the faith

[Jay]

Hey Jayman my team consists of the following:-


Royalz-With-Cheese
   
Back line: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, P.Duffield,  T.Armstrong, L.Stevenson, B.Goodes.
Reserves:
(D.Terlich, J.Frost)

Mid: G.Ablett, D.Beams,K.Jack, T.Cotchin, D.Rich, M.Duncan, J.Viney, J.O'meara
Reserves:
(N.Kommer,  K.Mitchell)

Rucks: W.Minson, M.Blicavs
Reserves:
(D.Currie, S.Rowe)

Forwards: T.Rockliff, D.Cox, M.Robinson, J.Bartel, K.Harper, P.Karnezis.
Reserves:                     
(J.Neade, B.Maccafer)

# Question is mate thinking of doing two trades and changing Armstrong to pittard as there playing Gws this week and then upgrading Harper to Siposs. What do you think and if you think I should mate and if those trades are viable or if you know of anything else I can do to alter and make my team solid. Thanks mate.

Well Armstrong is dropped so he has to go. Pittard is a great choice, solid js and obviously has scoring potential as shown on the weekend.

Harper is an interesting one, think you should wait and see how he goes this week before trading

[Jay]

Hey Jayman -

Rucks - Roughhead, Bellchambers
(bench) Daw, Blicavs

Forward -Cox

I dont know what i was thinking but wanted roughy for DPP and his average and everyone talked up Bellchambers.
I just traded both of them to Goldstein and Jacobs. (or can go Goldstein and Maric).
Loose my DPP with Cox as i dont have Row but meh..
Goldstien and Jacobs didn't play very well and stilll got 121 and 102.
Roughy played a forward pocket role with no ruch time and bellchambers only got 70 from a solid performance, so would need a miracle game ot get 110.

Thoughts?  8)

You traded Belly and Roughy :o

Mate I think you at least need to give them another week to prove themselves. Hold fire mate

[Jay]

Rioli+kommer or matty wright+ b. hill/ k.stevens

Wright and Kommer. Spend the cash elsewhere?

[Keeper27]

so this is my team after Rnd 1.... 2310 with NO GAJ.

BJ, Gibbs, Hanley, Russell, Goodes, Pittard (stevenson/Brown)

Swan, Pendles, JPK (c), Fyfe, Mundy, Wines, O'meara, Jones (Kommer/Crouch)

Cox, Giles (blicavs/daw)

Rocky, Bartel, Zorko, JJK, Karny, Macaffer (Neade/Rowe)



i know its silly to trade after Rnd 1, but i really want GAJ/Viney/Terlich & Goldy.

over the next 2 weeks should i trade Russell/Fyfe/Giles/Jones for those guys as i feel they will earn me a LOT more points and a LOT more money??

or should i wait a few weeks take a hit on Giles and see how Leuey goes?? but i still want GAJ/Viney/Terlich LOL

[LF]

I'm pretty happy with my team and it scored well last week despite the Embley and Stevens vests.
So I'm doing a fix it trade by going Embley --> Viney
This gives me more than enough cash to trade Rich to a premo if I want this will give me a 5 premo midfield with still around $90k in the bank.
But I'm not sure whether to give Rich another week or not
What are your thoughts?

Current mids
Ablett,Pendles,Swallow,Jack,Rich,Embley,Stevens,O'Meara,Kommer,Jones

[Jay]

so this is my team after Rnd 1.... 2310 with NO GAJ.

BJ, Gibbs, Hanley, Russell, Goodes, Pittard (stevenson/Brown)

Swan, Pendles, JPK (c), Fyfe, Mundy, Wines, O'meara, Jones (Kommer/Crouch)

Cox, Giles (blicavs/daw)

Rocky, Bartel, Zorko, JJK, Karny, Macaffer (Neade/Rowe)



i know its silly to trade after Rnd 1, but i really want GAJ/Viney/Terlich & Goldy.

over the next 2 weeks should i trade Russell/Fyfe/Giles/Jones for those guys as i feel they will earn me a LOT more points and a LOT more money??

or should i wait a few weeks take a hit on Giles and see how Leuey goes?? but i still want GAJ/Viney/Terlich LOL

nice team mate :)

Think you should stick with your current team for now mate and asses again next week before the prices change. Gotta get Ablett though!

[Jay]

I'm pretty happy with my team and it scored well last week despite the Embley and Stevens vests.
So I'm doing a fix it trade by going Embley --> Viney
This gives me more than enough cash to trade Rich to a premo if I want this will give me a 5 premo midfield with still around $90k in the bank.
But I'm not sure whether to give Rich another week or not
What are your thoughts?

Current mids
Ablett,Pendles,Swallow,Jack,Rich,Embley,Stevens,O'Meara,Kommer,Jones

I think Rich should go Luv. Just can't scoe well when he is getting the no.1 tag every week. I would get on Viney and upgrade Rich. Should be set once you have done that

[jfitty]

What are your thoughts on Duffield so far Jayman?

He's actually doing okay, with scores of 80 and 91, but I'm wondering if I should be trying to swap him for Birchall or Waters. I've had some decent luck and could spare a trade to do it, however my instincts tell me it's way too sideways.

[Jay]

What are your thoughts on Duffield so far Jayman?

He's actually doing okay, with scores of 80 and 91, but I'm wondering if I should be trying to swap him for Birchall or Waters. I've had some decent luck and could spare a trade to do it, however my instincts tell me it's way too sideways.

You know what I'd stick with Duffield mate. He has not scored so low that he is worthy of a trade. Could be better used elsewhere :)

[Keeper27]

Karny > Monfries
Russel > Dixon
(take a $25K loss on giles and if Leuey gets another 100+ jump on him?)

or

Karny > Monfries
Kommer > Mullet
(take a $25K loss on giles and if Leuey gets another 100+ jump on him?)