Ask Jayman

[TheViper]

yeh i have cox as the swingman that's why. sorry to confuse you.

[TheViper]

Yeh i just have a feeling with lucas is that his DE is going to let him down and that he will be the first dropped when Scotalnd comes back into the team.

[TheViper]

Sorry to bother you again.

but i've got another combo for you.

Colquorhn, mcevoy, neade vs lucas, leuy and petterd??

The first one is the safer one. But neade and colqourhn will be on my bench anyway. But i feel like i need leuy and and a F6 that is not Mccaffer so i can have mcaffer as cover just in case of injuries.

[colmullet]

do you think its best to start Cox in the rucks due to the poor forward rookie options i can then put Rowe as F8 so that solves that pesky rookie slot and you would think Witts/Currie/Daw/Blicavs are a better chance to play over the first few rounds then Neade/Lee/Paparone.....?

[Jay]

Sorry to bother you again.

but i've got another combo for you.

Colquorhn, mcevoy, neade vs lucas, leuy and petterd??

The first one is the safer one. But neade and colqourhn will be on my bench anyway. But i feel like i need leuy and and a F6 that is not Mccaffer so i can have mcaffer as cover just in case of injuries.

Could you choose someone better than Pettard? That option if you don't get Pettard...

[Jay]

do you think its best to start Cox in the rucks due to the poor forward rookie options i can then put Rowe as F8 so that solves that pesky rookie slot and you would think Witts/Currie/Daw/Blicavs are a better chance to play over the first few rounds then Neade/Lee/Paparone.....?

Good question. I see everyone with Cox in their fwds but like you, I am not sure why... I think the ruck rookies beat the forward rookies, just.

[Dooga]

With gaj, pendles, danger, hannebery, Lucas and rookies as my midfield, and cox and z smith in the ruck would you...

1. Have jpk or deledio and 70-50 thou spare cash
Or
2. Have mundy and Monfries up forward and no cash really
Or
3. Upgrade z smith to anyone below sandilands

???

Think ya missed my question jayman..?

[Jay]

With gaj, pendles, danger, hannebery, Lucas and rookies as my midfield, would you...

1. Have jpk or deledio and 70-50 thou spare cash
Or
2. Have mundy and Monfries up forward and no cash really

???

Sorry about the wait :-\

Who would that fwd be if you went with JPK (he is better than Lids)?

Think I would want to monitor Monfrie's first couple of games before jumping on

[Dooga]

It could be anyone under about 370...

I'm not sold on jjk and varcoe, and I've already got karnezis...?
Maybe upgrading z smith is the way or even grabbing tony Armstrong down back?

[Dooga]

Sorry I misread that, I would be starting macaffer if I went with jpk...

[Jay]

Sorry I misread that, I would be starting macaffer if I went with jpk...

So JPK + Macaffer vs. Mundy + Monfries?

I like Gus as a pick but think JJK would be better. I'd take JJK and Mundy over JPK and Macaffer.

[Dooga]

Sorry I misread that, I would be starting macaffer if I went with jpk...

So JPK + Macaffer vs. Mundy + Monfries?

I like Gus as a pick but think JJK would be better. I'd take JJK and Mundy over JPK and Macaffer.

Mmm very intriguing, thanks for the advice mate!

[Clyde Frog]

Should we keep Brad Crouch or trade him to a playing rookie?

[tor01doc]

Get a playing rookie.

If Crouch (best case scenario) starts week 2 you'll still get to jump on before he rises.

Only downside is JS of the playing rookie you select - eg Viney, K Mitchell, etc - if you assume they'll play, then 3 weeks of them and swap to Crouch if he kills it and is on the bubble.

[MTTY]

Hey Jay,

My midfield premiums at the moment are: Ablett, Pendlebury, JPK and Deledio

Does that look alright/strong enough?