Ask Jayman

[Jay]

Hey J, what do you reckon about Robert Warnock as a staight swap if Berger doesn't get up in time for rd 1?

I dont think he has the mobility to be a good SC scorer. Would prefer Bellchambers or Zac Smith.

[spryburrito]

Jayman! Question on Currie....

Was going with a balanced team of:
R: Jacobs, Smith (Rowe, Currie)
F: Cox, zorko, rockliff, martin, JJK, Karnezis/Varcoe (Macaffer, Lee) plus 4 prems + 2 rooks on field in DEF and 4 super prems (+600k) /4 rooks on field in MID.

...but thought that with the rise of Currie that I could get away with Jacobs, Currie, Rowe and maybe a Witts in the rucks and Cox, zorko, rockliff, bartel, martin with JJK at F6 to beef up the forwards.

Cox can cover if Currie doesn't get a gig and Macaffer or Lee can hold F6. Thoughts?

[Jay]

Karnezis has had a great NAB series and pre-season... but Brisbane seem to have plenty of depth-
My question is will he find a regular enough place to risk him @ F5/F6??

Rohan Bewick, Stefan Martin, Todd Banfield
Ashley McGrath, Jonathan Brown, Tom Rockliff,
Aaron Cornelius, Green, Paparone, Mayes,
Zorko rolling forward too

I have Karnezis in front of alot of them. Ringo will know more than me but with Karnezis getting mid time he will definitely be worth F5/6.

Tough choice between him Varcoe and Byrnes but I think he has shown enough this pre-season to warrant selection :)

[Locinator]

2 Questions Jay,

1) Would you go for Colqourn or Vlaustin price is irrelevant

2)Thoughts on Chris Knights

Loving the work mate.

[Jay]

2 Questions Jay,

1) Would you go for Colqourn or Vlaustin price is irrelevant

2)Thoughts on Chris Knights

Loving the work mate.

1. If price is no issue then definitely Vlastuin. See him playing far more games than Colq

2. Knights is an interesting one, would prefer to pick him in DT tbh. Would much rather go with Karnezis, Byrnes or Varcoe in SC. Chuck in Cornelius too as a smokey...

[Aussie2]

Who do you rate more out of Ward and McLean

[Jay]

Who do you rate more out of Ward and McLean

I would take Wade but neither would be ideal. Sloane, Swallow or even Stants may be better bets in the mid-high 500's price range

Even Fyfe/Mundy would be better and you save cash :)

[doogz]

Hey Jayman,
Would you have Mundy+Dusty v Cotchin + JJKennedy.  Thanks!

[Jay]

Hey Jayman,
Would you have Mundy+Dusty v Cotchin + JJKennedy.  Thanks!

I would go Mundy and Dusty

I think Mundy will back to his best this season and Cotchin won't be too far in front of him as his price suggests. Dusty is set to explode and although JJK is a good pick, he won't be as good as Dusty.

[Torpedo10]

Hey Jay,

Who do you recommend as the best starting ruck combo for 2013? Cheers

[Jay]

Hey Jay,

Who do you recommend as the best starting ruck combo for 2013? Cheers

Hard question to answer Torp since you have not given me how much you have to spend. So I would say Cox and Maric will be the best ruck combo.

However I am operating a Mcevoy/Bellchambers combo that I believe to be great value for money as both will improve in 2013.

[roo boys!]

Hey Jayman,
Would you have Mundy+Dusty v Cotchin + JJKennedy.  Thanks!

On a similar note,

JPKennedy+JJKennedy v Mundy+Zorko?

Cheers :)

[Jay]

Hey Jayman,
Would you have Mundy+Dusty v Cotchin + JJKennedy.  Thanks!

On a similar note,

JPKennedy+JJKennedy v Mundy+Zorko?

Cheers :)

Another tough one but I think I would go Mundy + Zorko.

Simply because the difference betweem Zorko and JJK will be bigger than JPK > Mundy

[Jay]

Am loving helping you guys out, please keep them coming :)

If you want to repay the favour and help me out I would love a rate on my team... http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74267.0.html

Or a vote in personality of the year would be nice... http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71340.0.html

[DoctorRush]

Love the effort ur puttin in Jayman.
Lots of time and effort to give back to FF users! Great work!