Selwood or Murphy?

[Dazzler1536]

Cant decide, help!

[Ricochet]

Tough one, can you get both in? Can see them both hitting 120+ so purely based on price I will say Marc

[liam32]

In my opinion, go for Murphy, but if you can get both do it

[fever]

murphy. both guns, but selwood's concussion potential is a concern for me

[Bluesman]

Selwood reasonably comfortably -  from a Bluesman!

[Slammer]

Murphy. Reckon he will float forward even more this year and kick goals.

[Dazzler1536]

Added poll, vote!

[Blues Blues Blues]

Tonight's performance not filling me with a lot of confidence in Murphy I have to say

[Dazzler1536]

Yes, am very worried now   ??? hmmm..

[tor01doc]

If you can't decide, don't know, or can't find a coin to flip, then it is time to acknowledge that your choice is going to be best made by taking the byes and the other players you've selected into consideration.

For instance, if you have GAJ / Swan or Pendles and Danger - then Selwood.

If you have a lot who share Selwood's bye, then Murphy.

[Dazzler1536]

Looks like this one is in Selwoods favour then - my midfield stands as Ablett Pendles Danger Selwood AND Murphy (looking to possibly downgrade one of them to a fyfe) K.Mitchell O'Meara Viney Crouch

[Ricochet]

Tonight's performance not filling me with a lot of confidence in Murphy I have to say

Dont read too much into NAB when it comes to proven performers
Last year Swan only scored 46 and 74 in NAB and Jelwood went 105 and 66

[quinny88]

Murphy. He is underpriced and will avg around 120

[tor01doc]

Hey, just a thought regarding the cost of a donut come round 13,

Say you only have 17 players you can field.

You lose say 80 points. This is about 4 per game averaged out over 20 rounds.

Doesn't sound like much, but this means Murphy will actually average 116 instead of the 120 proposed above.

Lots of teams very heavy on round 13ers.

[sammy123]

murph did not likw the tag last night. Doesn't cope well with a tag. Remember a few times last year he couldnt cope