Who for M5?

[pinochio]

good points....

comes down to redden vs murphy.....just afraid that murphy can have tag affected scores now that its universally accepted he has kinda overtaken judd....

[Toga]

Redden won't be tagged, plays the same game as Matty Boyd so there is literally no point tagging him, would be completely ineffective. BUT a lot of his points come from tackles, which he hasn't been doing much over NAB cup - I know NAB is NAB and some people don't take it seriously but it is a bit disheartening to see him only get one tackle across three games...

Murphy - I'm still not convinced about the whole tagging issue either, but tbh I think he CAN break them but still an element of risk involved in selecting him.

[pinochio]

so who you thinking toga out of the pack???

[powersuperkents]

good points....

comes down to redden vs murphy.....just afraid that murphy can have tag affected scores now that its universally accepted he has kinda overtaken judd....

Yeah the tag is a factor. I think you are going to have to throw Jelwood in the mix as well. The kid is unique, consistent and had past seasons of 103, 106, 109 & 103. Jelwood is along with Murphy are the safest bets, just depending on how much the potential tag affects your faith in Murphy (I think he will still go 110-115). Also do you have Rockliff in your forwards because you should consider the RedRock combination. I think Rocky could average anywhere between 90-115 and Redden should easily make 108-112 so just think about whether that is the right choice for you. Hardly anyone has the combo as well and personally my plans are to eventually upgrade my F5 & F6 to Stevie J and Zorko (if Zorko continues a run between 95-105) so I can have all three of the lions. I believe that those three players are going to carry the team this season (dt wise) and should all reach 100+ averages. I still call Zorko to average 95-98 though.

Just check out Jelwood and Murphy past season statistics because they should really help make up your mind 

[Toga]

so who you thinking toga out of the pack???

My personal favourite out of the bunch is Redden - reckon he'll get back up to around 110 this season...

Selwood i can see improving again up to maybe 108ish...

ROK is a smokey though - reckon he will be huge over the first five or so rounds if you want a POD.

[pinochio]

roks too old :P

whats the advantage in the redrock combo can be the murphrock combo ;) ???

but ye guys i think im leaning to redden atm....

[powersuperkents]

roks too old :P

whats the advantage in the redrock combo can be the murphrock combo ;) ???

but ye guys i think im leaning to redden atm....

haha
Murphrock doesn't sound as good :)
Go Redden I think he's my starting M3 for this season after Swan and Pendles and followed by Murphy in M4 and Fyfe in M5

[pinochio]

yep redden is my M5 as we speak :)